top of page

Contact Us

Yes, we can help.
You talk.
We listen.

When you call our office for the first time, you will be greeted by Cathy Vinciguerra. Having managed our Firm for several years, Cathy plays the important role of legal emergency triage: she will ask questions to determine immediacy, deadlines, and risk.
 

She is very, very good at what she does. As a member of the legal team, all communication with Cathy is confidential and protected by the attorney-client privilege. As a result, the first topic Cathy will ask about will be the names of other parties involved in the situation to ensure there is no conflict of interest.
 

We know that this may be the most stressful event in your life right now. We try to schedule our initial meeting as quickly as possible so that we can begin investigation as close in time to the events as possible. Given the situation, Cathy will ask you for information to make sure that the attorney you speak with is the best match for your case situation, even if it is not the lawyer who you were referred.

Questions to expect during a potential client intake call:


Every situation is different.


Because Cathy has interviewed thousands of people over the years, expect to be asked
fact-specific questions about your legal situation.


​

  • Most of our clients are referrals from lawyers. Who referred you to our office? What is your relationship with that lawyer? How much have you explained to them? Would you want us to speak with them first to get an understanding of the case?​
     

  • Sometimes legal cases involve multiple persons. I want to make sure that we haven’t already spoken with somebody else that may preclude us from working with you. Does this situation involve anybody else? Who does the dispute involve? What are the names of essential witnesses in the case?

​

  • Have you been represented by any other lawyer in this matter? Are you seeking a Second Legal Opinion?

​

  • Some people are highly sophisticated consumers of legal services; others have never been in this situation before and want as much information as possible. How much detail and explanation do you want so that we are giving you what you need right now?

​

  • Have you personally been involved in civil litigation or the criminal justice system before? In what capacity?

​

  • What is your biggest concern/anxiety about this matter that we would need to address first?

​

  • What is the most important fact or detail about your case that we should know in order to give you accurate legal advice?

Questions?
 

Contact our office to discuss your case. We're here to help.

Give us a call

Mon - Fri

8:30 am – 5:30 pm

Our office, by appointment only

1100 B Guadalupe St, Austin, TX 78701

We have reserved client parking at 1100 Guadelupe

Who do you represent?

Most of our clients are professionals who have never been in trouble before. Our ideal client is a sophisticated legal consumer who appreciates the caliber of work and strategy and diplomacy that we provide to our clients. We also represent businesses who are served with grand jury subpoenas or who are the target of federal, state, administrative or regulatory violations.

What kind of criminal cases do you handle?

We handle every type of criminal, regulatory, administrative or disciplinary matter. Were you accused of doing something wrong? We handle it.

How long have you been doing this?

Do you think this grey hair is from playing golf?

Is there a type of client you won't represent?

People that are demeaning or degrading to our staff; people that seek to use our legal services to conceal an ongoing fraud; people who are aggressive and confrontational.

Do you believe in the death penalty?

No.

I want my teenager to meet with you because I believe they are using drugs and may get arrested. Will you do this? Is it confidential?

Harm reduction. Nudge.

Will you take my criminal case pro-bono?

No. Every person facing incarceration is provided counsel if they cannot afford a lawyer. We work within this system. We are appointed to represent indigent clients in serious cases, and our pro bono work does not involve direct representation for people who are eligible to receive court appointed counsel or a lawyer through the Volunteer Legal Services.

How do I know that I'm not overpaying for legal services?

I would feel like I overpaid if I didn't receive the results I wanted. The question is: was it a waste of money? Assuming you only pay $1.00, you will still feel like you overpaid if you don't trust your lawyer, if you don't want to hire a lawyer, and you don't value legal services. The sole question is: how much do you want us to work in order to achieve results? If you believe the matter should be resolved in 15 minutes and we believe it will take 30 hours - we're going to be in conflict unless you adjust your goals. Ultimately, you are the sole arbitrator for the range of legal services. There are two ways to pay for our legal services: by the hour or through a fixed fee agreement. Our commodity is our time and our advice. We trade these for money. We work hard, we work efficiently, we do good work, and we must earn a profit - no matter what fee arrangement.

How much should I pay for representation?

Initially, you should receive a greater value than what you pay for. Once the point of diminishing marginal utility approaches, you should strongly re-evaluate your budget for legal fees. Second, we believe money spent trying to prevent a legal problem is far more cost-effective than trying to undo a catastrophe. For example, appealing a motion to suppress is far more expensive than paying for a few hours of legal advice about whether to meet with a detective and give a statement. Third, set your legal fee budget based upon the seriousness of the matter, the result you want, and the amount of time it will take to achieve that result. This last factor is the most difficult to gauge.

What is your consultation policy?

Our consultation fees depend upon the advice - and the urgency of the advice needed.
While each situation is different, the general rule is that questions that begin with, “What
should I do...” is a consultation for purposes of seeking legal advice. Full legal
representation may be unnecessary, and a single consultation for a fixed fee will often
suffice. Federal white collar cases, criminal investigations, protective orders, and
Second Legal Opinions also fall in this category.
When interviewing lawyers when you have a known scope and objective - such as
seeking representation in a plaintiff’s case or in civil or criminal defense - it is more akin
to interviewing a primary care physician. The purpose of the consultation is a joint
interview: the potential client interviewing the lawyer for knowledge and skill and
integrity, and the lawyer interviewing the client for goodness-of-fit. The time preparing
for the consultation and the work performed during the meeting are only billable if you
choose to retain the Firm.
You will never be sent a bill for calling Cathy to ask questions, so when in doubt, she is
the best point of contact about consultations.

If I am simply under investigation for a federal offense and haven't been charged for a crime do I need an attorney?

Yes. To help protect your rights, you should contact an attorney right away. The investigation phase is crucial for the defendant, and statements that are made or not made to law enforcement officers could change the outcome of the case for better or worse. To have an attorney at this point is very important.

Where do you practice?

It depends upon the seriousness of the case. For federal matters we practice across the United States. Otherwise, we practice throughout the state of Texas. A majority of our cases are in Central Texas. David is also licensed to practice in California.

How many cases like mine have you handled?

Your case exactly? None, unless we've represented you before. Even cases with the same charges and similar accusations and the same arresting officer and the same judge and the same prosecutor can be fundamentally different based upon your individual situation. However, we keep track of the thousands of cases we've worked on in a meticulous database to help identify cases similar to yours to help you see our history of our work, our strategy, our results, the length of time it took to achieve those results, and the cost to achieve the results.

How do I know that you will do a good job for me?

1) Look at past results in cases with similar facts as you, 2) ask yourself how much work you're willing to do to help with your defense, and 3) ask question after question after question after question. Our answers should help give you the data to judge our ongoing performance before you receive a final result.

Have you ever declined to represent somebody that offered to pay your fee?

Yes.

When can I meet with you?

The afternoons are typically the best as we spend most of our mornings in court. Cathy and our paralegals have up-to-the minute updates of our calendars and can schedule a meeting as brief as 15 minutes or as long as several hours with you.

When should I hire a lawyer?

We believe the best use of a lawyer is to help you build a fence at the top of a cliff instead of helping you in the ambulance after falling over one. If you are under investigation, if you have been accused of wrongdoing, or if you've done something questionable and you want to make things right, this is the perfect time to engage the Firm.

When do I have to pay you?

When you want to engage our Firm. After meeting with you to discuss representation we will calculate an Engagement Retainer that will serve to hire us as your law Firm.

What are the questions a good client asks a lawyer?

Why do you practice this area of law? How is your practice different? Can you describe your typical client? Is this your ideal client? How do you handle disagreements with your clients? What do you believe I need to know in order to make a good decision about my case? What are your academic credentials?

How much should I budget for legal fees?

*************

Should I hire a lawyer to get somebody out of jail or a bail bondsman?

Obviously we're biased. We set out the advantages of hiring a lawyer here and here. If
you are arrested and facing criminal charges, you have to have a lawyer.  You don't have
to hire a bondsman.  From a purely economic standpoint, it is financially advantageous
to avoid duplicating costs. Furthermore, we know that legal fees are expensive, but we
don't charge $1,000.00 an hour. Even assuming you pay your heart surgeon or brain
surgeon $5,000.00 an hour during an operation (well worth the cost),  it seems
unconscionable to pay so $1,000.00 or more for a bail bondsman to sign some papers
for you to be released. There is a difference between professional services and the often
predatory practices of bondsman, loan sharks, and pawn dealers.
One could say this is like the shark warning you to stay away from the piranha. Both of
our businesses are often viewed as a necessary evil. All that being said, we often do refer
clients to bail bondsman when they are able to provide a service cheaper, faster, or more
effectively than we can.  In some cases we will refer you to a bail bondsman because the
county doesn't allow lawyer-assisted bonds. Other times we will suggest using a bail
bondsman if its a matter that only a judge can decide and he or she won't be back on the
bench for days. If a person is looking only to get out of jail and is likely to qualify for a
court-appointed lawyer, we will refer him to a bail bondsman. The same is true for
outstanding warrants for unpaid tickets or very minor matters where time-sensitive
legal advice is unnecessary, we absolutely concede that a bail bondsman is the better
choice.
However, for more serious cases like DWI, assaults, and felonies; for cases in which it is
crucial that we photograph marks on your face or your arms to prove your side of the
story; for cases involving high bond amounts or pending criminal investigations in which a detective may be trying to talk you - we feel strongly that this is a critical role
that we play in your defense that go beyond merely getting you out of jail.

What kinds of law do you practice?

Primarily federal and state criminal law. This includes representing people accused of a crime--but also witnesses and victims in civil proceedings. Under this purview, we handle professional license matters, school disciplinary proceedings at colleges and universities throughout the state, and juvenile and school related work.

How well do you know the law?

Every time the legislature meets we're part of the criminal defense team that advises the House and Senate of the Texas Legislature on criminal justice. We're part of the small group of lawyers that understands the new laws because we often were present when the provisions were drafted, revised, edited, and codified into law.

You have young children. Would you ever represent a child molester?

Yes, precisely because we have young children and are aware of some of the incredible, unbelievable statements that can come out of our kids' mouth. Once a statement from a child is made, the accused is tainted with an unforgivable sin that can never, ever be purged. Think of it: even if the person is exonerated a trial, the public belief is "his lawyer got him off." People do molest children. Child abuse is real, and we have worked with people to ensure that they receive much needed treatment and counseling. But we also know that many allegations spring from ugly child custody disputes, misinterpretation, and childhood ideation.

Are you ethical?

I would hope that we would be described as such. It is difficult to describe yourself with positive attributes like honesty, fairness, or integrity without calling into question those very characteristics.

Are there any types of cases you won't take?

We won't take cases in which we have a conflict of interest. Otherwise, the cases we accept are based upon the characteristics of the client, not the accusation. We've had incredible relationships with people arrested for murder and terrible relationships with clients who sought our help with traffic tickets. There is no case beneath us. If it matters to our client, it matters to us.

How should I decide on a lawyer?

First, personality and fit. How is the lawyer's bedside manner? Would you work well together? Second, feel. Is this the person you want speaking for you in court? Is this somebody you would be proud to say is your lawyer? Third, trust. Will the lawyer work hard to advocate for your interests? Will the lawyer have the integrity to give you news that you may not want to hear?

I'm afraid that I'm paying for your nice law offices, fancy sports car, and lake house and that you are overcharging me.

We are professional negotiators. Do you honestly believe a group of people that negotiate hour after hour every day is going to pay market price for anything? We had very fruitful negotiations for our office space. You can check the parking lot to see that we don't have reserved spots. If we did, you'd find some pretty boring, safe family cars. A lake house would be nice, but we have kids to put through college.

Be honest: what does a lawyer do that is so special that you can charge hundreds of dollars an hour? That strikes me as outrageous.

Think of a lawyer's billable hour rate in terms of the number of hours of R&D that went into becoming a lawyer. In my situation, I had no social life in high school because every weekend was spent in debate tournaments. These 10,000+ hours provided my foundation in public speaking, cross-examination, research, analysis, and argument. My work paid off: we won the state championships and finished in the top ten in the nation. While my college freshman celebrated their newfound freedom, I continued with collegiate debate. I spent weekends studying to earn the grades to get into one of the best law schools in the country. While at Stanford, I kept working and practicing oral argument and advocacy while also knocking down my tuition costs by teaching Stanford undergraduate students. Even after passing the bar exam I spent many years apprenticing with experienced trial lawyers for free in order to gain valuable experience inside the courtroom. This continues today with our work teaching, writing, and continuing to study law for your benefit. In order to do good legal work, you invest several hundred thousand dollars in education, and more than 40,000 hours of study and work. The computer guys at Best Buy charge $100.00 an hour to look at your computer. Your mechanic, your plumber and your electrician charge similar rates. In comparison, legal fees are far less given the financial investment when compared to other service industries. Legal fees are not trivial, but neither are the consequences.

How can Sumpter, Gonzalez, and Carroll help me with the ALR hearing?

When hired in time, we request this hearing for you. Regardless of who requests the hearing, we always attend these hearings. At the hearing, we question the arresting officer to contest the suspension of your license and make legal and factual challenges to the items listed above.
We also view this hearing as our first chance to how the arresting officer stands up to cross-examination regarding your case and find out what he or she remembers and says about you. We then use this information to prepare your defense for trial or negotiations with the prosecutor.

How much legal work or legal advice can you really get done in jail?

Depending upon the case, a tremendous amount. It isn't a question of being in jail, it is knowing the questions to ask a client in order to preserve evidence that may be destroyed or altered before the client gets out of jail. Furthermore, because of the size of our Firm and our ability to quickly marshal resources in serious cases, we are able to call upon each other in an emergency to get things done while the primary lawyer is in jail meeting with the client. In the past years we have been able to preserve evidence at the scene of an intoxication manslaughter before the rain washed evidence away; photograph red marks on a client's arm which proved his version of the events and led to a case's dismissal; meet with the victim and mediate a dispute and misunderstanding which resulted in all charged being dropped; dispute the signs of intoxication or impairment which were exaggerated in an offense report. We have also stopped interrogations, preventing felonies from being filed, and resolved cases with the District Attorney before the client was even released from jail.

Sometimes time is of the essence, and the sooner we can respond, the better the result for the client.

Sumpter, Gonzalez, & Carroll, LLP. All Rights Reserved. Principal Office: Austin, Texas. David M. Gonzalez is Board Certified in Criminal Law. 

bottom of page