
Who What When Where Why WTF?
Why The Face?
Confusion is our speciality.
Like the Firm but don't know if we handle your type of case?
We’re happy to provide referrals.
For example, we won’t file a divorce petition – but we’ve frequently be involved with a spouse makes an allegation of wrongdoing during the divorce. We don’t handle personal or corporate immigration visas, but we are hired to ensure an arrest doesn’t result in guaranteed removal or deportation.
What is the difference between a litigator and a trial lawyer?
To a layperson, there is no difference. But to a trial lawyer, there is a fundamental difference between lawyers that specialize on working inside the courtroom compared to lawyers that focus on discovery battles outside the courtroom.
Why do lawyers say “attorney and counselor at law?” Is there a difference?
Attorney. Lawyer. Counselor. Solicitor. Barrister. All describe the same professional, but some terms describe a more specific skill than others.
Your question, answered
Who do you represent?
Most of our clients are professionals who have never been in trouble before. Our ideal client is a sophisticated legal consumer who appreciates the caliber of work and strategy and diplomacy that we provide to our clients. We also represent businesses who are served with grand jury subpoenas or who are the target of federal, state, administrative or regulatory violations.
Where do you practice?
It depends upon the seriousness of the case. For federal matters we practice across the United States. Otherwise, we practice throughout the state of Texas. A majority of our cases are in Central Texas. David is also licensed to practice in California.
What kinds of law do you practice?
Primarily federal and state criminal law. This includes representing people accused of a crime--but also witnesses and victims in civil proceedings. Under this purview, we handle professional license matters, school disciplinary proceedings at colleges and universities throughout the state, and juvenile and school related work.
What kind of criminal cases do you handle?
We handle every type of criminal, regulatory, administrative or disciplinary matter. Were you accused of doing something wrong? We handle it.
How many cases like mine have you handled?
Your case exactly? None, unless we've represented you before. Even cases with the same charges and similar accusations and the same arresting officer and the same judge and the same prosecutor can be fundamentally different based upon your individual situation. However, we keep track of the thousands of cases we've worked on in a meticulous database to help identify cases similar to yours to help you see our history of our work, our strategy, our results, the length of time it took to achieve those results, and the cost to achieve the results.
How well do you know the law?
Every time the legislature meets we're part of the criminal defense team that advises the House and Senate of the Texas Legislature on criminal justice. We're part of the small group of lawyers that understands the new laws because we often were present when the provisions were drafted, revised, edited, and codified into law.
How long have you been doing this?
Do you think this grey hair is from playing golf?
How do I know that you will do a good job for me?
1) Look at past results in cases with similar facts as you, 2) ask yourself how much work you're willing to do to help with your defense, and 3) ask question after question after question after question. Our answers should help give you the data to judge our ongoing performance before you receive a final result.
You have young children. Would you ever represent a child molester?
Yes, precisely because we have young children and are aware of some of the incredible, unbelievable statements that can come out of our kids' mouth. Once a statement from a child is made, the accused is tainted with an unforgivable sin that can never, ever be purged. Think of it: even if the person is exonerated a trial, the public belief is "his lawyer got him off." People do molest children. Child abuse is real, and we have worked with people to ensure that they receive much needed treatment and counseling. But we also know that many allegations spring from ugly child custody disputes, misinterpretation, and childhood ideation.
Is there a type of client you won't represent?
People that are demeaning or degrading to our staff; people that seek to use our legal services to conceal an ongoing fraud; people who are aggressive and confrontational.
Have you ever declined to represent somebody that offered to pay your fee?
Yes.
Are you ethical?
I would hope that we would be described as such. It is difficult to describe yourself with positive attributes like honesty, fairness, or integrity without calling into question those very characteristics.
Do you believe in the death penalty?
No.
When can I meet with you?
The afternoons are typically the best as we spend most of our mornings in court. Cathy and our paralegals have up-to-the minute updates of our calendars and can schedule a meeting as brief as 15 minutes or as long as several hours with you.
Are there any types of cases you won't take?
We won't take cases in which we have a conflict of interest. Otherwise, the cases we accept are based upon the characteristics of the client, not the accusation. We've had incredible relationships with people arrested for murder and terrible relationships with clients who sought our help with traffic tickets. There is no case beneath us. If it matters to our client, it matters to us.
What do I do if I receive a grand jury subpoena?
If you have been subpoenaed to testify before a grand jury, in a criminal trial, or in any kind of criminal proceeding, it is incredibly important to consult with an attorney and protect your rights. A lawyer can advise you about your own potential liability, help limit your exposure to criminal charges if it becomes necessary to assert your Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, or work to get you immunity from
prosecution.
Is the criminal justice system fair?
To quote Winston Churchill, "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others that have been tried." I think there are severe problems with the overrepresentation of blacks and Latinos in prison. I believe any system that uses mass incarceration to deal with medical problems like addition and mental illness is unjust. I believe the process of electing trial judges, appellate judges, and prosecutors leads to unnecessarily punitive results. But I believe in juries. And I believe in a majority of people who work in the system. And I believe some people have to make amends for harm they have caused. I'm just not convinced that we've achieved the goals that our justice system is capable of.
When do you have to be read your Miranda rights?
************
What are the police prohibited from lying about?
The police may not lie about a specific sentence or grant of immunity. Thus, the police will talk in general terms like, "I'll make sure to tell the DA to go easier on you because you were cooperative." You cannot make a contract with the police for a specific outcome. They do not have that authority. While they may imply that they do, when pushed, they are not allowed to commit and therefore will not lie about it because it could invalidate the voluntariness of the confession.
Is a police officer allowed to lie to me?
********Yes. There are numerous examples when police officers have used photocopiers and called them polygraph tests, lied about the presence of DNA at the crime scene, lied about eyewitnesses, lied about confessions, and lied about anything and everything in order to obtain incriminating statements. There is one thing that the police may not lie about, however,
How long will it take for my case to be resolved?
It depends upon your goal, the opposing party's goal, and the length of time to either find a compromise or for one party to convince the other side that they are wrong. Sometimes there is never a meeting of the minds and the parties ask a judge, jury, mediator, or arbitrator to decide the case.
Explain the law that applies to my case.
There are five sources of law that will apply to your criminal case: the penal code, the code of criminal procedure, the rules of evidence, and the state court and federal court opinions that interpret the statutes in each applicable area. The law that governs the crime may be straightforward, the but police procedure to obtain evidence may be problematic. Similarly, there may be evidence that corroborates guilt but it may not be admissible in court. We specialize in this exhaustive legal inquiry.
Explain why cases get reset so often.
Most often it is because something is missing, like a report or a test or a witness statement (discovery) and both sides want to have reviewed all the information before making an offer/counter-offer to resolve a dispute. Other times there is no agreement about the value of a case and the lawyers want more time to see if a settlement can be reached. There is no need for the case to be reset if either side wants to concede. This often happens during jail call (the jail reduction docket) where indigent defendants who cannot bond out of jail plea guilty in exchange for accepting a sentence for the number of days they were waiting in jail for court.
Why didn't the police read me my rights?
Because either you weren't in custody, you weren't being interrogated, or they decided that they didn't need to because they already have enough information to arrest you. Most of the time it's because you were free to leave, and Miranda only applies to custodial interrogations.
Why did the police search me?
How do I know that you didn't have a gun or knife hidden in your boot that you would use against the officer? How do I know whether you're going to try to sneak something into the jail? It's called a search incident to arrest.
Why did the police impound my car?
If you had a passenger in your car, sometimes the police will allow your passenger to drive home or permit another person to come to the scene and take possession of your car. Other times it is easier for them to impound. One of the advantages of impounding your car (from the police perspective) is that it then provides them with the legal right to search your entire car (an inventory search).
Why don't they just dismiss my case if I've never been in trouble before?
Can they prove the case? If so, the prosecutor believes that it is in the interest of justice to hold you accountable for violating the law, even if it's your first offense. However, it is certainly easier to argue for a dismissal or reduction with no prior criminal history--but it is not dispositive. It also depends upon the seriousness of the offense. In response to an argument I made during the punishment phase of a murder trial where my client had never been in trouble before the prosecutor told the jury, you don't get one free murder.
Where is the main courthouse?
The Blackwell-Thurman Justice Complex is located in the white high-rise at 509 West 11th Street.
Where is the juvenile courthouse?
Gardner-Betts is located at 2515 South Congress at the intersection of South Congress and Long Bow Lane. Once you pass the metal detectors you will check in with the receptionist who will point you in the direction of the courtrooms. You'll wait in the lobby until the probation officer checks in with you.
Where is the federal courthouse?
The new federal courthouse is located at 501 West Fifth Street between San Antonio and Nueces Street.
What do I say if I want to get out of jury duty?
Please don't. We need good jurors. We need the jury system, and with far fewer jury trials every year - trial lawyers need to do everything we can to encourage active participation in this public service. You would be a good juror for the right case. Your work could help decide important issues in your community. If you can, please make arrangements so you can participate in a jury trial. The lawyers in the Firm have cleared their calendars to be able to participate in grand jury and petit jury service. We loved it. Everybody who participates in trial comes away with an awesome feeling of how the system works. Don't pass up the opportunity.
Can I have my case transferred to a different judge?
No. Are you related to the judge? Is the judge a witness? The judge would be recused. Otherwise, we have no choice over which judge will hear your case.
Why didn't I go to jail and got a ticket instead?
Because you were either polite and respectful to the officer, or the officer didn't want to bother booking you into jail for a lower level offense. The process is called "cite and release" and it was designed to keep police officers back on the streets instead of waiting to process paperwork at the jail.
Why did it take so long to get out of jail?
Did you get the feeling that if McDonald's ran the training program the system would be much more efficient? The process is part of the punishment.
I thought the U.S. Supreme Court said the police couldn't forcibly take a person's blood?
Not so much. The police may still get a search warrant and forcibly obtain your blood. The McNeely case was really about whether the fact that alcohol dissipates from blood allows the police to draw blood without a warrant due to exigent circumstances. The Supreme Court rejected this analysis and requires a case-by-case decision.
I thought I passed all the sobriety tests. Why was I arrested?
How do you defend a mentally ill person charged with a crime?
When are there deadlines I should be aware of?
Depending upon the case and the jurisdiction--there are many. In DWI cases, you have to file a Request for Hearing to stop the automatic suspension of your driver's licenses within 15 days of your arrest. In appeals you have 30 days to file a Motion for New Trial and a Notice of Appeal. For pretrial diversion or similar programs there are application deadlines. There are deadlines to file motions, deadlines to file an election for punishment if conviction, deadlines to file an application for probation, and deadlines to file for continuances. None of these are particularly difficult--they are just scattered throughout the Texas Penal Code and Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.
I want my teenager to meet with you because I believe they are using drugs and may get arrested. Will you do this? Is it confidential?
Harm reduction. Nudge.
What happens if I am arrested and I am not a U.S. citizen?
This is a very, very serious question that cannot be answered easily. The most important advice is: if you are not a U.S. Citizen you should never, ever plead guilty to any crime before speaking with both an immigration lawyer and a criminal defense lawyer.
How much time does it take to prepare for trial?
I've heard that trial is expensive and everybody wants to avoid trial. Why?
*******There are two costs to trial: transaction costs (legal fees) and outcome risk (verdict). The two are intimately correlated: the greater the risk of an
When should I hire a lawyer?
We believe the best use of a lawyer is to help you build a fence at the top of a cliff instead of helping you in the ambulance after falling over one. If you are under investigation, if you have been accused of wrongdoing, or if you've done something questionable and you want to make things right, this is the perfect time to engage the Firm.
How should I decide on a lawyer?
First, personality and fit. How is the lawyer's bedside manner? Would you work well together? Second, feel. Is this the person you want speaking for you in court? Is this somebody you would be proud to say is your lawyer? Third, trust. Will the lawyer work hard to advocate for your interests? Will the lawyer have the integrity to give you news that you may not want to hear?
Will you take my criminal case pro-bono?
No. Every person facing incarceration is provided counsel if they cannot afford a lawyer. We work within this system. We are appointed to represent indigent clients in serious cases, and our pro bono work does not involve direct representation for people who are eligible to receive court appointed counsel or a lawyer through the Volunteer Legal Services.
When do I have to pay you?
When you want to engage our Firm. After meeting with you to discuss representation we will calculate an Engagement Retainer that will serve to hire us as your law Firm.
I'm afraid that I'm paying for your nice law offices, fancy sports car, and lake house and that you are overcharging me.
We are professional negotiators. Do you honestly believe a group of people that negotiate hour after hour every day is going to pay market price for anything? We had very fruitful negotiations for our office space. You can check the parking lot to see that we don't have reserved spots. If we did, you'd find some pretty boring, safe family cars. A lake house would be nice, but we have kids to put through college.
How do I know that I'm not overpaying for legal services?
I would feel like I overpaid if I didn't receive the results I wanted. The question is: was it a waste of money? Assuming you only pay $1.00, you will still feel like you overpaid if you don't trust your lawyer, if you don't want to hire a lawyer, and you don't value legal services. The sole question is: how much do you want us to work in order to achieve results? If you believe the matter should be resolved in 15 minutes and we believe it will take 30 hours - we're going to be in conflict unless you adjust your goals. Ultimately, you are the sole arbitrator for the range of legal services. There are two ways to pay for our legal services: by the hour or through a fixed fee agreement. Our commodity is our time and our advice. We trade these for money. We work hard, we work efficiently, we do good work, and we must earn a profit - no matter what fee arrangement.
What are the questions a good client asks a lawyer?
Why do you practice this area of law? How is your practice different? Can you describe your typical client? Is this your ideal client? How do you handle disagreements with your clients? What do you believe I need to know in order to make a good decision about my case? What are your academic credentials?
Be honest: what does a lawyer do that is so special that you can charge hundreds of dollars an hour? That strikes me as outrageous.
Think of a lawyer's billable hour rate in terms of the number of hours of R&D that went into becoming a lawyer. In my situation, I had no social life in high school because every weekend was spent in debate tournaments. These 10,000+ hours provided my foundation in public speaking, cross-examination, research, analysis, and argument. My work paid off: we won the state championships and finished in the top ten in the nation. While my college freshman celebrated their newfound freedom, I continued with collegiate debate. I spent weekends studying to earn the grades to get into one of the best law schools in the country. While at Stanford, I kept working and practicing oral argument and advocacy while also knocking down my tuition costs by teaching Stanford undergraduate students. Even after passing the bar exam I spent many years apprenticing with experienced trial lawyers for free in order to gain valuable experience inside the courtroom. This continues today with our work teaching, writing, and continuing to study law for your benefit. In order to do good legal work, you invest several hundred thousand dollars in education, and more than 40,000 hours of study and work. The computer guys at Best Buy charge $100.00 an hour to look at your computer. Your mechanic, your plumber and your electrician charge similar rates. In comparison, legal fees are far less given the financial investment when compared to other service industries. Legal fees are not trivial, but neither are the consequences.
How much should I pay for representation?
Initially, you should receive a greater value than what you pay for. Once the point of diminishing marginal utility approaches, you should strongly re-evaluate your budget for legal fees. Second, we believe money spent trying to prevent a legal problem is far more cost-effective than trying to undo a catastrophe. For example, appealing a motion to suppress is far more expensive than paying for a few hours of legal advice about whether to meet with a detective and give a statement. Third, set your legal fee budget based upon the seriousness of the matter, the result you want, and the amount of time it will take to achieve that result. This last factor is the most difficult to gauge.
How much should I budget for legal fees?
*************
How can Sumpter, Gonzalez, and Carroll help me with the ALR hearing?
When hired in time, we request this hearing for you. Regardless of who requests the hearing, we always attend these hearings. At the hearing, we question the arresting officer to contest the suspension of your license and make legal and factual challenges to the items listed above.
We also view this hearing as our first chance to how the arresting officer stands up to cross-examination regarding your case and find out what he or she remembers and says about you. We then use this information to prepare your defense for trial or negotiations with the prosecutor.
What happens if my license is suspended?
If your license is suspended, you may be granted an occupational license which allows you to drive to places such as work, school, child care, and the grocery store.
What if I don't request an ALR hearing in time?
If you do not request a hearing, the suspension will go into effect 40 days from the date the notice was sent. A fee of $125 will be charged to reinstate the license after the suspension period expires.
Is my license suspended if I get arrested for DWI?
Your license will be suspended forty days from the date of your arrest unless you request an ALR hearing to contest this suspension. You must request this hearing within 15 days from your arrest. When hired in time, we request this hearing for you.
Your license can also be suspended for up to 365 days if you are convicted of a DWI-1st and up to two years for subsequent convictions.
Should I take a blood test?
In Texas, when you are suspected of DWI, an officer has the "option" of asking you to submit to a breath or blood test. You are allowed to refuse both tests, but an officer may attempt to obtain a warrant for your blood from a judge. To issue a warrant, the judge must find that there is probable cause to believe you were driving while intoxicated. If a warrant is issued, you do not have a right to refuse the collection of your blood for blood alcohol analysis. While you must comply with a warrant, you can challenge a warrant that is issued without probable cause.
We recommend that you do not consent to a blood draw - even when pressured with the fact that the police will "go get a warrant anyway." Let them get a warrant - there's a decent chance the judge may refuse to sign the warrant even if the police ask them.
There are several factors that can interfere with a blood test. For example, if the person drawing your blood wipes your arm with an alcohol swab, creating an artificially high blood alcohol level. Furthermore, if there are improper levels of preservative in the tube used for drawing your blood, the blood sample can actually ferment, creating alcohol.
We sometimes have our clients’ blood samples independently tested to verify that the results were accurate.
Also, even if a blood sample was properly drawn and stored, it’s important to note that while chemical testing may be accurate to determine blood alcohol content (BAC) at the time of testing, it is not conclusive evidence of BAC at the time of driving. It is not illegal to be above the legal limit while in a police station; the crime is driving while intoxicated, or driving above the legal limit, not having a BAC above the legal limit at a later time.
Should I take a Preliminary Breath Test?
Blood Alcohol Content and Breath Tests
In Texas, when you are suspected of DWI, an officer has the "option" of asking you to submit to a breath or blood test. Texas allows you to refuse to take these tests, or any other test the officer may ask of him or her. But if the officer has a reasonable suspicion that you are over the legal limit, you will probably be arrested and taken to jail.
If you submit to breath testing, your breath will be tested using the Intoxilyzer 5000. The machine measures two samples of your breath about two minutes apart. Breath testing is commonly used by police because of its convenience. There are debates among scientists regarding the accuracy of breath tests, and we believe that breath testing is horrendously unreliable. Unlike blood and urine tests, you cannot retest breath samples for accuracy.
Furthermore, many factors can cause an inaccurate reading, such as having recently pumped gasoline, burped, having diabetes, etc.
What are the penalties for refusing a breath test?
1) a suspension of driving privileges for 90 days if it's your first arrest for DWI
2) a 180 day suspension for a subsequent arrest if, in the first arrest you refused to submit to testing or had an alcohol concentration of .08 or greater
3) a one year license suspension if you have a prior conviction for DWI
4) admission into evidence that you refused to take the breath test in the subsequent DWI criminal trial.
What makes a DWI a Felony?
Felony DWI
There are two types of felony DWIs: driving while intoxicated with a child passenger and habitual offenders.
Child passenger: You can be charged with a state jail felony if suspected while driving while intoxicated and you have a passenger younger than 15 years of age. This can mean up to two years in a state jail facility.
Habitual offenders: You will be charged with a third degree felony if arrested for driving while intoxicated and have two or more previous DWI convictions. This can mean 2-10 years in the penitentiary and a fine up to $4,000.
With such high stakes at risk, it is important to hire an attorney who can protect you on all fronts - we immediately review the police officer's information in your case to determine whether there was legal authority to stop or arrest you. We then evaluate the videotape of your field sobriety tests from multiple perspectives - from how we think a jury would evaluate your performance to whether your tests were conducted in accordance with the standards required by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
What is the difference between a DWI and a DUI?
In Texas, there is a different standard of proof for intoxication offenses committed by those less than 21 years old. Under the zero tolerance laws, a prosecution for Driving Under the Influence (DUI) occurs when a person who does not have the legal privilege to consume alcohol has any detectible amount of alcohol in their system. If you are under 21 and the police officer pulls you over and smells a faint odor of alcohol on your breath, the officer will testify that he has probable cause for a DUI arrest. Anybody over 21 years old cannot be arrested for DUI. DUI is a class C misdemeanor which carries a punishment of a fine up to $500.
As the offense name implies, Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) requires a higher burden of proof in comparison to DUI. While mere odor may be sufficient to trigger arrest when you have no legal right of consumption (hence, under the "influence"), those older than 21 must have lost the normal use of their physical or mental faculties or have a blood alcohol content of .08 or above to be deemed "intoxicated" under the law. DWI is a class B misdemeanor which carries a punishment range of up to 180 days in jail and/or a fine up to $2,000.
You do not have to be over 21 to be arrested for DWI; a person under 21 can be arrested for either DUI or DWI. However, given the higher burden of proof associated with proving a DWI case, persons under 21 are more often arrested for DUI.
Why was I pulled over?
Possible Reasons you were pulled over and may have been arrested
A police officer must have a "reasonable suspicion" that you violated the law in order to pull you over. There are many reasons completely unrelated to intoxication that a law enforcement officer can justify pulling you over and temporarily detaining you, including the following:
-Weaving, crossing over lane boundaries
-Tailgating
-Speeding or driving too slowly
-Slowing down and speeding up repeatedly
-Erratic driving
-Failure to signal a lane change
-Running a stop sign or traffic light
-Making an improper turn
-Driving without headlights or taillights
-Expired registration
...and the hundreds of other minor moving violations which you could be cited for.
Can you ever get off the sex offender registration list?
Sex Offender Deregistration
Nearly a decade ago, the legislature allowed early termination of an adult’s obligation to register retroactively. The idea is that there are many young, first-time offenders engaged in consensual sexual activity with an underage person (statutory rape) that should be treated differently than sexual predators. However, in order for this to occur the Council on Sex Offender Treatment must create an Individual Risk Assessment in order to determine who would be eligible for early termination.
It took many, many years to develop the risk assessment tool to determine eligibility. As of 2010, the Council on Sex Offender Treatment provided the following update:
“During the 79th Regular session of the Texas Legislature, two companion bills became law which potentially impact deregistration of some sex offenders in Texas. First, H.B. 867 amended Chapter 62, Code of Criminal Procedure, by adding Subchapter I, Art. 62.401 et seq., thereby creating a potential deregistration exemption for certain non-aggravated first-time sex offenders, after those offenders have been registered for a minimum of ten (10) years. This delayed exemption is limited to those sex offenders which currently require lifetime registration under Texas law, but who are only subjected to a ten (10) year registration requirement under Federal law.
The five specific penal code offenses which are subject to deregistration under Art. 62.404 are: Indecency with a Child (Section 21.11(a)(1); Promotion and Distribution of Child Pornography (Section 43.26); Burglary with Intent (Section 30.02); Sexual Performance of a Child (Section 43.25); and Compelling Prostitution of a Child under 17 (Section 43.05(a)(2). The Legislature did not consider the deregistration of other sexual offenses to avoid violating the Jacob Wetterling Act which would cause the state to risk losing 10% of the annual federal grants it receives in the form of Edward Byrne Memorial funds.
The provisions of H.B. 867, however, cannot be implemented without a consideration of H.B. 2036. In amending Chapter 110, Occupations Code, the Legislature charged the Council on Sex Offender Treatment with “developing, researching, implementing, and deploying dynamic risk assessment tools and protocols for the use of individuals licensed under this chapter for the purpose of determining a sex offender’s risk to the community”. Similarly, H.B. 867 requires the Council by rule to “establish, develop, and/or adopt an individual risk assessment and/or a group of individual risk assessment tools and to evaluate persons using those tools”. Thus, Occupations Code § 110.501, and Art. 62.403, Code of Criminal Procedure, are to be read in conjunction with each other regarding the issue of sex offender risk assessment tools and protocols in Texas.
In October 2005, the Council began its Dynamic Risk Assessment Research project. The goal of this project is to collect research data from a variety of risk assessment tools which in turn can be used when considering deregistration issues. While the Council’s research project is well underway, deregistration as contemplated by the Legislature under H.B. 867 will not occur immediately. On July 2006, the President signed into law House Resolution 4476 (Adam Walsh Act) pertaining to sex offender registration. This broadened sex offender registration nationally and impacted the above referenced offenses from consideration for deregistration under Texas law. The Adam Walsh Act does allow Tiered 1 offenders to potentially deregister after 10 years, and Tiered 3 offenders to deregister after 25 years with a clean record and having completed sex offender treatment. There is no deregistration for Tiered II offenders who must register for 25 years.”
List of Eligible Offenses
Not all persons who are registered sex offenders are eligible to pursue deregistration in Texas. The amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure, Chapter 62 allow sex offenders who have been convicted or placed on deferred adjudication for the following offenses to pursue deregistration:
● Compelling prostitution
● Compelling prostitution (victim under 17 years old)
● Indecent exposure (two or more convictions)
● Unlawful restraint (victim under 17 years old)
● Indecency with a child by exposure
● Possession or promotion of child pornography
● Online solicitation of a minor
● Sexual performance of a child
● Indecency with a child (victim 13 to 17 years old)
● Any attempts, conspiracies, and solicitations of any of the above listed.
Waiting Period
You must have been registered as a sex offender for a minimum of ten (10) years. The Texas sex offender deregistration remedy is limited to those sex offenders which currently require lifetime registration under Texas law, but who are only subjected to a ten (10) year registration requirement under Federal law.
Prerequisites to Deregistration Application
● You must not being convicted of any offense for which
imprisonment for more than 1 year may be imposed during the required registration period;
● You must not have been convicted of any sex offense including misdemeanors during the required registration period;
● You must have successfully completed sex offender treatment as defined in 22 Texas Administrative Code, Section 810.2(b)(29); and
● You must have successfully completed any periods of supervised release, probation, and parole. Any revocation disqualifies the offender.
Thus, sex offenders who are currently on probation or parole are not eligible for deregistration until they have successfully completed their community supervision.
Evaluation
The Council on Sex Offender Treatment developed a protocol for the deregistration process that utilizes research supported risk assessment instruments. The Council trained qualified Licensed Sex Offender Treatment Providers who are listed as Deregistration Evaluation Specialists. These Specialists will be the professionals who are qualified to conduct the deregistration evaluations that could potentially provide a Registered Sex Offender with an opportunity to seek relief from the court regarding his or her obligation to register.
Hearing
An individual who undergoes a deregistration evaluation is not guaranteed that he or she will be relieved from the duty to register. The final decision whether or not to allow the sex offender to deregister is ultimately determined by the judge in the original court of jurisdiction. The court reviews the applicant’s petition to terminate sex offender registration and conducts a hearing. Very often the underlying facts of the case play a critical role in the judge’s determination of whether the application should be allowed to deregister.
Are there different classifications of sex offenders?
Risk Levels:
A numeric risk level indicates the level of risk a sex offender poses to the community. A numeric risk level is assigned to each sex offender when the offender is released from a penal institution or placed on community supervision or juvenile probation. It is determined by using the sex offender screening tool adopted by the Risk Assessment Review Committee. There are three different risk levels:
Level one (low): indicates that the person poses a low danger to the community and will not likely engage in criminal sexual conduct.
Level two (moderate): indicates that the person poses a moderate danger to the community and may continue to engage in criminal sexual conduct.
Level three (high): indicates that the person poses a serious danger to the community and will continue to engage in criminal sexual conduct.
Each level is based on a point system derived from the danger the person poses to the community or the likelihood that the person will continue to engage in criminal sexual conduct. The numeric risk level assignment impacts the intensity of the offender’s registration requirements, and can determine, among other things, whether or not there is a neighborhood notification requirement. DPS will notify local law enforcement when a registered sex offender moves to its area. That local law enforcement authority must then verify with DPS the registrant’s numeric risk level within eight days of receiving the risk level notice.
What are the restrictions on registered sex offenders in Texas?
Distinction Between Restrictions Resulting From Registration Versus Restrictions That Are A Condition Of Probation Or Parole
Because there are so many restrictions placed upon a person accused of a sex related offense, it is difficult to keep track of the authority for each restriction. As a general rule, the mere fact that a person is registered as a sex offender does not prohibit a person from doing anything; the only additional criminal liability imposed by registration is that failure to register is a felony offense.
Restrictions related to unsupervised contact with minors, polygraph examinations, residency restrictions, and employment restrictions are all conditions of parole or probation. Texas probation and parole law requires the imposition of a “child safety zone” on a sex offender placed on community supervision (probation) or released on parole or mandatory supervision if the offender’s victim was a child. A “child safety zone” prohibits sex offenders on community supervision, parole, or mandatory supervision from supervising or participating in any program that includes as participants or recipients persons 17 years of age or younger and that regularly provides athletic, civic, or cultural activities or going in, on, or within a specified distance of a premises where children commonly gather (i.e. schools, day care facilities, or playgrounds). A violation of the “child safety zone” can result in the revocation of a sex offender’s probation or parole and, consequently, incarceration. This “child safety zone” lasts for as long as the sex offender is on community supervision, parole, or mandatory supervision. Similarly, the Texas Sex Offender Registration Program itself does not prohibit registered sex offenders from working in certain trades, occupations or professions.
However, this is where the “collateral consequences” conversation begins again. While the sex offender registration statute does not prohibit where a person can live or work, other state laws that regulate a particular trade, occupation or profession may bar sex offenders from working in the trade, profession or occupation. Likewise, private employers, neighborhood associations, and landlords can develop their own set of regulations which exclude registered sex offenders.
How long does sex offender registration last?
Each sex offense is correlated to a mandatory length of sex offender registration. Most sex offenses carry a lifetime registration requirement; a few have a ten year registration requirement.
Registered sex offenders must report all changes in address to the proper local law enforcement authorities seven days before an intended change in address. If the person moves to another state, he or she has ten days after arrival in the other state to register with the law enforcement agency that is identified by the Texas Department of Public Safety as the agency designated by that state to receive registration information.
In addition to providing notification of all address changes, registered sex offenders have seven days to provide notice about changes in the offender’s name, physical health, job status, and educational status. Furthermore, if the person spends more than 48 consecutive hours in a municipality or county, other than the municipality or county in which the sex offender is registered, for more than three times in a month, he or she must report that fact to the local law enforcement authority of the municipality or county in which the offender is visiting. In reporting this fact to the proper local law enforcement authority, the sex offender must provide all the information that is required for sex offender registration, the address of any location in the municipality or county at which the offender was lodged during the month, and a statement as to whether the offender intends to return to the municipality or county during the succeeding month.
All registered sex offenders who either work at or enroll in a public or private institution of higher education (university, college, community college, or technical or trade institution) must provide notice of that fact to two different entities. First, the offender must notify the authority for campus security (i.e. campus police department) for the institution of higher education that the offender has begun to work or attend school at the institution. Second, the offender must notify the offender’s primary registration authority of the offender’s work or enrollment at the institution of higher education. These notifications must be provided no later than the seventh day after the date the offender begins work or enrollment at the institution of higher education. The offender must also notify the authority for campus security and primary registration authority when the offender terminates work or enrollment at the institution of higher education. This notification must be provided no later than the seventh day after the date the offender terminates work or enrollment at the institution.
What is your consultation policy?
Our consultation fees depend upon the advice - and the urgency of the advice needed.
While each situation is different, the general rule is that questions that begin with, “What
should I do...” is a consultation for purposes of seeking legal advice. Full legal
representation may be unnecessary, and a single consultation for a fixed fee will often
suffice. Federal white collar cases, criminal investigations, protective orders, and
Second Legal Opinions also fall in this category.
When interviewing lawyers when you have a known scope and objective - such as
seeking representation in a plaintiff’s case or in civil or criminal defense - it is more akin
to interviewing a primary care physician. The purpose of the consultation is a joint
interview: the potential client interviewing the lawyer for knowledge and skill and
integrity, and the lawyer interviewing the client for goodness-of-fit. The time preparing
for the consultation and the work performed during the meeting are only billable if you
choose to retain the Firm.
You will never be sent a bill for calling Cathy to ask questions, so when in doubt, she is
the best point of contact about consultations.
How long will jail release take?
On average, it takes 4 to 6 hours for the Sheriff to release someone from custody once all
the paperwork is turned in. Before the jail release process begins, however, a lawyer
must interview the client, gather background information, fill out the bond
paperwork, obtain the probable cause affidavit, and meet with a judge who signs off on
the bond. There are a number of steps, and one of our main jobs is to both expedite the
process and keep the client informed of what is happened so they are less anxious and
know that they will be getting released soon.
How is bond amount determined?
After reading the police officer’s Probable Cause Affidavit (an abbreviated police report)
and cross-referencing guidelines that magistrates try to follow for purposes of
unanimity, the judge will set a bond amount. Some magistrates will want information
about whether the victim feels safe before setting a bond amount; others will want to
know a person's criminal history before setting bond. The magistrate has unbridled
discretion to set a bond in any amount. If he or she wants to set a bond for $100,000.00
on a possession of marijuana case, it is so ordered. At that point, it is incumbent upon
the lawyer to file a writ and set the issue for a bond reduction hearing to argue that the
bond amount is excessive. Different magistrates set higher bonds than others on certain
types of cases, but most stay within a pretty predictable range depending upon the facts
outlined in the Probable Cause Affidavit.
Why hasn't a bond been set?
For any number of reasons: the person may have just been arrested and is still being
processed in Central Booking; there may have been a large number of people arrested
and there's a long line at processing; the police officer hasn't turned in his Probable
Cause Affidavit and so the magistrate doesn't know the facts in order to set a bond; etc.
Every person will eventually have a bond set. It often just takes a while. One of the
things we do is try to speed the process by helping compile information for the
magistrate to make it easier and faster for him or her to set a bond.
Should I hire a lawyer to get somebody out of jail or a bail bondsman?
Obviously we're biased. We set out the advantages of hiring a lawyer here and here. If
you are arrested and facing criminal charges, you have to have a lawyer. You don't have
to hire a bondsman. From a purely economic standpoint, it is financially advantageous
to avoid duplicating costs. Furthermore, we know that legal fees are expensive, but we
don't charge $1,000.00 an hour. Even assuming you pay your heart surgeon or brain
surgeon $5,000.00 an hour during an operation (well worth the cost), it seems
unconscionable to pay so $1,000.00 or more for a bail bondsman to sign some papers
for you to be released. There is a difference between professional services and the often
predatory practices of bondsman, loan sharks, and pawn dealers.
One could say this is like the shark warning you to stay away from the piranha. Both of
our businesses are often viewed as a necessary evil. All that being said, we often do refer
clients to bail bondsman when they are able to provide a service cheaper, faster, or more
effectively than we can. In some cases we will refer you to a bail bondsman because the
county doesn't allow lawyer-assisted bonds. Other times we will suggest using a bail
bondsman if its a matter that only a judge can decide and he or she won't be back on the
bench for days. If a person is looking only to get out of jail and is likely to qualify for a
court-appointed lawyer, we will refer him to a bail bondsman. The same is true for
outstanding warrants for unpaid tickets or very minor matters where time-sensitive
legal advice is unnecessary, we absolutely concede that a bail bondsman is the better
choice.
However, for more serious cases like DWI, assaults, and felonies; for cases in which it is
crucial that we photograph marks on your face or your arms to prove your side of the
story; for cases involving high bond amounts or pending criminal investigations in which a detective may be trying to talk you - we feel strongly that this is a critical role
that we play in your defense that go beyond merely getting you out of jail.
I am trying to get a friend or family member out of jail. I want to help, but I don't want to commit them to hiring you to represent them in the underlying case?
Perfect - we agree with you. We are not bail bondsman - and we don't want to encroach
on their business model of helping people who are looking to pay as little as possible to
get out of jail without any thought or concern about their future criminal case. While we
think this is a pretty shortsighted approach to an arrest, for some people it's just not that
big of deal.
For most of our clients it is a big deal, and who they choose as their criminal defense
lawyer is even a bigger deal. Just as most people have a primary care physician, in an
emergency you don't care which doctor you see in the ER, you need medical attention
stat. We feel the same way about a legal emergency. While we differ from the ER in that
we develop long-term attorney-client relationships often after helping somebody get out
of jail, hiring Sumpter, Gonzalez, and Carroll at the outset doesn't preclude you from meeting with
or hiring any other lawyer in the universe to defense against the underlying case. In fact,
we often encourage our clients to consult with other lawyers so that they choose the best
lawyer for their defense. If it's not us, then we still have provided a valuable service
during a time of crisis.
How much legal work or legal advice can you really get done in jail?
Depending upon the case, a tremendous amount. It isn't a question of being in jail, it is knowing the questions to ask a client in order to preserve evidence that may be destroyed or altered before the client gets out of jail. Furthermore, because of the size of our Firm and our ability to quickly marshal resources in serious cases, we are able to call upon each other in an emergency to get things done while the primary lawyer is in jail meeting with the client. In the past years we have been able to preserve evidence at the scene of an intoxication manslaughter before the rain washed evidence away; photograph red marks on a client's arm which proved his version of the events and led to a case's dismissal; meet with the victim and mediate a dispute and misunderstanding which resulted in all charged being dropped; dispute the signs of intoxication or impairment which were exaggerated in an offense report. We have also stopped interrogations, preventing felonies from being filed, and resolved cases with the District Attorney before the client was even released from jail.
Sometimes time is of the essence, and the sooner we can respond, the better the result for the client.
How do you post a bail bond in federal court?
Detention Hearings:
When you are arrested on a Federal Crime, most likely, you will be held in jail until you have a hearing before a judge or magistrate. Unlike the state criminal justice system where you can post bond to get out of jail, all the money in the world cannot buy your way out of federal pretrial detention.
The federal system operates different from state criminal courts. Unlike the state system, most first time offenders in the federal system will spend time in federal prison. (When domestic diva Martha Stewart and Olympic champion Marion Jones and movie star Wesley Snipes all serve time in prison on a first offense, you get the idea that the system is remarkably harsh.) As a result, the Federal Magistrate must constantly weight the risk of whether the defendant will come back for further court hearings and face a possible prison sentence. Given the seriousness of most federal criminal penalties, simply paying a few thousand dollars to a bail bondsman isn't the kind of security that magistrates look for in making a release decision.
In more serious cases, the judge will assume you should be detained unless your lawyer can make a very convincing argument that you will not be a "flight risk" (meaning you will show up in court when you are supposed to do so) and that you will not be a danger to yourself or others if you are not in detention. In all cases, the legal team has a very short window of time to develop a witness list, produce evidence showing that you have strong ties to the community, and create a release plan to address the issues surrounding the client's home, work, and family life which will convince the judge to take the risk of letting you out of jail.
In federal criminal defense, the detention hearing may be the most crucial stage that determines how the case will be handled. If the client is released, he can be far more productive in assisting in his own defense. If detained, the pressure is to resolve the case as soon as possible and the client's ability to participate in his defense is more limited. So it is really important that we get involved from the very beginning.
What is the difference between a federal and state crime?
A federal crime is a violation of a statute passed by the United States Congress. A state crime is a violation of a statute or ordinance passed by the state legislature or a local authority. Many crimes could be prosecuted in both state and federal courts.
Who investigates and prosecutes federal crimes?
Federal criminal offenses are usually investigated by agents of federal agencies such as the FBI, DEA, ATF, Secret Service, etc... Occasionally, state law enforcement officers work with federal agencies. Federal crimes are usually prosecuted by the United States Attorney’s Office in the area where the crime was committed.
Do I need a "federal" defense attorney if I am charged with or under investigation for a federal crime?
Yes. Your lawyer must be licensed to practice law in federal court where the case is pending. Because the federal court system is different than the state court system, it is important your attorney has experience in federal court.
If I am simply under investigation for a federal offense and haven't been charged for a crime do I need an attorney?
Yes. To help protect your rights, you should contact an attorney right away. The investigation phase is crucial for the defendant, and statements that are made or not made to law enforcement officers could change the outcome of the case for better or worse. To have an attorney at this point is very important.
Can you really be sentenced to probation for murder?
Two of our clients who were charged with murder are successfully serving sentences of community supervision. How is that possible? Because it was the right sentence for both clients given the facts, the circumstances, and their role in each unrelated offense.
If a person convicted of murder has never previously been convicted of a felony, the jury can choose a sentence from a $1.00 fine to life in prison. After hearing all the facts, the jury has the power to decide that while a person may not have been legally entitled to a self-defense claim, he certainly doesn't belong in prison. Similarly, a jury may feel that a defendant's violent criminal history is so disturbing that he should be sentenced to prison for decades.
Sentencing decisions in murder cases often find their basis in religious, moral, and retributive grounds.
What are the consequences of having to register as a sex offender
Conditions of Registration
A person who is required to register as a sex offender must provide the following information pursuant to Article 62.051(c):
1. the person’s full name, each alias, date of birth, sex, race, height, weight, eye color, hair color, social security number, driver’s license number, shoe size, and home address;
2. a recent color photograph or, if possible, an electronic digital image of the person and a complete set of the person’s fingerprints;
3. the type of offense the person was convicted of, the age of the victim, the date of conviction, and the punishment received;
4. an indication as to whether the person is discharged, paroled, or released on juvenile probation, community supervision, or mandatory supervision;
5. an indication of each business, occupational, or professional license, certificate, permit, or other authorization issued by a licensing authority that is held or sought by the person;
6. an indication as to whether the person is or will be employed, carrying on a vocation, or a student at a particular public or private institution of higher education in this state or another state, and the name and address of that institution; and
7. any other information required by the Texas Department of Public Safety.
This information is considered public information except for the person’s social security number, driver’s license number, telephone number and information that would identify the victim. If additional information is required by DPS under the catchall of Article 62.051(c)(7), it is also considered nonpublic.
A person subject to sex offender registration registers with the local law enforcement authority of the municipality (police station) where he or she resides. If the person does not reside in a city, he registers with the local law enforcement authority of the county (sheriff’s office) where the person resides. Registration must be completed not later than the seventh day after the date the person arrives in the municipality or county or the first date the local law enforcement authority of the municipality or county by policy allows the person to register. Once the person registers with the local law enforcement authority of the municipality or county where s/he resides, that local law enforcement authority becomes the person’s primary registration authority.
If a sex offender resides outside of Texas and works or attends school in Texas, the person registers with the local law enforcement authority of the municipality or county where the offender works or attends school.
Ironically, most law enforcement agencies make it complicated for a person to register. In many jurisdictions a person cannot simply walk in on the last day and register without an appointment. Every local law enforcement authority has different procedures, and unless you are familiar with the local rules, a client may miss the deadline to register even if he started the process within seven days.
What crimes require sex offender registration?
Article 62.001(5)(H) of the Code of Criminal Procedure lists the following offenses that are classified as a “reportable conviction or adjudication”:
-Indecency with a child
-Sexual assault
-Aggravated sexual assault
-Continuous Sexual Assault of a Child
-Prohibited sexual conduct (Incest)
-Indecent Exposure (second adjudication)
-Compelling prostitution
-Sexual performance by a child
-Possession or promotion of child pornography
-Online solicitation of a minor
-Aggravated kidnapping if the respondent committed the offense with intent to violate or abuse the victim sexually
-Burglary of a habitation with intent to commit a specific sexual offense
-Unlawful restraint, Kidnapping, or Aggravated Kidnapping if the victim or intended victim was younger than 17 years of age
-Any attempt, conspiracy, or solicitation to commit an aforementioned offense (except indecent exposure)