top of page

Our portfolio

We can’t win every single case. But we can help every single client.

We win most of our cases, but we help all of our clients.
Our cases keep winning long after they’ve been decided.
 
We’ll put our win/loss record up against anyone. But when you approach law differently,
you also measure the effectiveness of your craft on a different scale. For us, we define
success as getting our clients back to the lives they had before the problems cropped
up [or even a better life], but armed with a new set of tools to avoid ever having legal
problems again.
 
To clearly show how our method works, we’ve developed a number of case studies in
depth, showing everything but the names of our clients. We
think you’ll find that every case is equally important to us, and as such, receives our full
attention.  
In addition, even though the legal system will lose interest in you at some point, we
won’t. We’re committed to reducing crime and breaking people out of destructive
patterns, and we’ve
developed a legal approach like no other law firm in order to make this happen. 
So we make sure to check in with our clients from time to time to make sure they’re still
pursuing a path in life that will lead them towards success and away from any further
legal complications. At Sumpter, Gonzalez, and Carroll, we believe in our clients and we’re
invested in their success, so we’re always eager to see our clients again.
 
Just not in a courtroom.

Real Client Results by Case Type

Result:

Dismissed

Murder

When police are called to the scene of a man lying on the street unresponsive, his son and witnesses report a hit and run. However, when a fatal gunshot wound to the head is discovered, a homicide investigation began. Our client drove to the scene after her friend called her reporting an altercation with her ex-boyfriend outside an apartment complex. Both women reported trying to drive around the man’s vehicle, but when he tried to enter our client’s vehicle through the window, she pulled the gun from her lap and shot him in the head. A past victim of human-trafficking, our client relied on her self-defense instincts when her friend’s ex with a history of abuse threatened her verbally and physically. We were able to show the court that due to her past abuse, our client was vigilant and alert to threats, acting in fear for her life when she shot the decedent.

Result:

Dismissed

Super Aggravated Sexual Assault of A Child (Two counts)

During a messy divorce, our client’s wife made an awful accusation: sexual assault of their two daughters. He was arrested and charged with two counts of Super Aggravated Sexual Assault of a Child. Our team conducted extensive research into child psychology and found factors present in the divorce that would contribute to child suggestibility and corroborate our client’s innocence. We presented our findings, and a passed polygraph, to the court and our client’s cases were dismissed.

Result:

Dismissed outright

Injury Child/Elderly/Disabled Criminal Negligence

After receiving treatment for a pressure ulcer and sepsis, our client's mother passed away in hospice care 10 days later. The grief our client felt, as her mother's caregiver as well, was

Result:

Dismissed outright

DWI

Our client expected his next stop to be the auto shop after accidentally rear-ending another driver at a red light, not the Travis County Jail. He hit the other car after failing to see it as he was turning and due to human error, caused a collision. However, when Officers responded to the scene, they immediately mistook our client’s neurological disorder, and resulting tremors, as intoxication and arrested him for a DWI. Despite blowing a 0.00 in a preliminary blood test, our client was wrongfully arrested and symptoms of his medical disorder were misinterpreted for probable cause. We got our client the dismissal he was entitled to.

Result:

All three charges dismissed

Indecent Assault, Indecent Exposure, Unlawful Restraint

When our client hears knocking at the door, he does not expect to be met with police officers and be placed under arrest. Earlier that day, he had met with a lawn care consultant for a measurement and estimate of his lawn. The lawn company’s employee had alleged that the homeowner, our client, grabbed, kissed her, and exposed himself in front of her without her consent further blocking the doorway so that she could not leave. He was arrested for Indecent Assault, Indecent Exposure, and Unlawful restraint after the employee filed a police report. The home’s security footage reflected our client’s account of the interaction—conversation regarding the lawn. We were able to get all three charges against our client dismissed, highlighting the lack of evidence to substantiate the allegations.

Result:

Charges dismissed and deferred to Mental Health Court.

Arson, Criminal Tresspass, Criminal Mischief

Officers respond to a disturbance after reports of glass breaking and sounds of physical violence. Upon arrival, officers hear banging and yelling coming from a locked apartment, followed by smoke and the activation of the unit’s fire alarm. When officers made entry, a growing fire had already consumed curtains and pile of items in the living room. Our client was detained leaving this apartment and entering a neighboring unit and was charged with Criminal Trespass of a Habitation, Criminal Mischief, and Arson (1st degree felony). What the police and prosecution were unaware of, however, was that our client was experiencing a mental health crisis at the time of the incident. Our social workers were able to assess the client’s mental health needs, determine a treatment plan, and put together a mitigation packet in order to petition this court that this matter best be handled in Mental Health Court. Our client’s three charges were all dismissed after successful completion of mental health diversion.

Result:

Theft dismissed and TBC held in order to get acquittal and immediate, low-cost expunction.

Theft

Client picked up jacket left by stranger in a bar. Charged with stealing the jacket and several hundred dollars that were in the jacket. Contacted complaining witness and discovered that witness would admit that although client had picked up the jacket, someone else had actually taken the money that was inside. State agreed to not only dismiss but have an abbreviated trial so that an acquittal could be obtained thereby allowing for an expunction right away at virtually no cost.

Read More

Result:

DWI dismissed

Driving While Intoxicated

Client allegedly failed the field sobriety tests, yet his blood test registered under the legal limit. The State still filed charges and refused to dismiss based upon the theory that client was under the influence of narcotics. Case was dismissed prior to trial.

Read More

Result:

Successfully continued on felony DWI probation

Driving While Intoxicated; Motion to Revoke Probation; Social Work

Client had numerous previous DWIs and was on felony probation for DWI. She violated probation by drinking alcohol and failing breath test interlock device. Instead of viewing the case as something that would be fought on a legal ground, we looked into ways that we could resolve it on a treatment basis. We were able to find a treatment counselor for our Client and set up a program for the Client to work with the third party counselor. The first condition of her probation was that she should immediately go into an in-patient therapy clinic. We contested this, arguing that the Client would do much better staying at her job and going to this private treatment provider. Unfortunately, during the time the case was being litigated, she had a relapse. Thankfully, the Judge did not revoke her probation and decided to allow the client to continue her private treatment. The Client was ultimately successful with this treatment.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Aggravated Sexual Assault of mentally incapacitated person (habitual)

Client was accused of the most serious sexual assault there can be: an aggravated sexual assault with a mentally incapacitated person. Interestingly, the mentally incapacitated person was over 21 and had the legal right to consent to sexual activity. The most interesting issue that we raised in this case is “can people who are mentally incapacitated ever consent to sexual activity?”

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Assault (juvenile)

Client was accused of assaulting another student at school. What started off as a simple assault during a game of tackle soccer turned into a more serious assault as the client had allegedly punched another boy. The teachers complained that client did not apologize for tackling the other boy, and when confronted, client said “I’m not going to apologize; I’d do it again.” As a result, child is referred to the SRO and formal assault charges are filed.

The significant problem with the case was that the other boy’s family was irate about the assault and were adamant about this case being charged as an assault against their son rather than just a playground scuffle, their son being a clear victim in their eyes. In this case, the parents of the victim and the teachers alleged that the physical interaction extended beyond the game. It took numerous conversations, counseling, and victim outreach to explore the differences between assaultive, criminal behavior and boys being boys. This case was resolved with the DA agreeing to dismiss the case if our client issued an apology and did some community service. We were able to take care of the case outside of the juvenile court system.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed prior to filing; no probable cause

Evading arrest (juvenile)

Client is arrested and family hires S&G to work on his release from jail. Client was accused of evading arrest on a bicycle, and after meeting with client in jail and investigating the scene, we prepare to litigate the issue of probable cause. After arguments at the detention hearing, judge agrees that there was no probable cause and releases client.

Read More

Result:

Civil suit dismissed

Civil suit – collection on debt (contested litigation)

After a contentious divorce which wiped out both parties’ assets, our client was stuck with massive payments on a truck that far exceeded its value. He returned the vehicle, but was being held liable for fees, costs, and lost profits by the car company. We responded to a collection suit and kept tabs on the plaintiff’s efforts over the years. After substantial time without action, plaintiff attempted to avoid a dismissal based upon failure to prosecute a claim by setting the matter for trial. The Court denied their motion and dismissed the collection suit entirely, saving client well over $12,000.

Read More

Result:

17 counts of Burglary of a Habitation dismissed

18 counts of Burglary of a Habitation

A group of boys went into what they thought was an abandoned warehouse. It turned out not to be abandoned but was part of a rather large gun shop. As the boys were inside, they had triggered a silent alarm to which the SWAT team responded around 3:00 A.M. Thankfully they were not shot because one of the boys had foolishly run out with one of the guns. Due to the outstanding restraint shown by the police, nobody was hurt. What happened over the next 24 hours is what made this case so incredibly interesting. The police did not contact our Client’s parents as they are supposed to under the Family Code. They also did not do the proper warnings of our Client, nor did they take him to a juvenile processing facility. Instead of taking him to Juvenile Court, they deliberately went to a different judge to get him magistrated. They then interrogated him for the next four or five hours without telling his mother, who was frantic by this time, and without knowledge of her child’s whereabouts. She contacted us during the process. During the course of that interrogation, our Client admitted to about 18 other entries to other buildings. We spent about 6 weeks doing research, going out to these buildings, and extensively researching the legislative history of the family code about these provisions we believed the police violated. We drafted a lengthy Motion to Suppress all of the statements. While preparing to begin the hearing, the DA conceded that the client’s rights were violated. Client agreed to pay restitution for the damage caused in other acts of criminal mischief and the state agreed to dismiss the other counts.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed; child not forced to register as a sex offender

Indecency with a Child by Contact (juvenile)

This case began with an alarming set of allegations: a group of boys were accused of taking a mentally ill girl and locking her into a closet and fondling her breast and buttocks against her will. After our interview with the client and in our investigation, we learned there was a pre-existing relationship with the victim and one of the boys involved; they had been dating and in fact were still dating when the offense occurred. We discovered that he and some other boys went over to her house and she and the other boys were kissing and engaged in quasi-sexual contact; Our client had nothing to do with it whatsoever. The incident she was referring to happened with another boy and was not of a sexual nature. The State then dismissed the case on all charges as more and more evidence of the falsity of the accusation came to light.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Assault (juvenile)

Juvenile client was charged with assault for pushing another kid at school. We were able to show that it was another kid and not our client; there were two issues of mistaken eyewitness identification and we worked hard to convince the prosecutor to review the case in this manner. All charges were dismissed.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; plea to lesser misdemeanor

Aggravated Assault with a Deadly Weapon--2nd Degree Felony

An argument between client and her brother got out of hand and client ended up waving a knife and threatening her brother after the two exchanged words and punches. This was a family squabble that escalated on both sides. The brother was not hurt and did not want to prosecute.

Read More

Result:

All charges dismissed

Assault – Family Violence

Our client, who was a PhD student at UT, was accused of assaulting his live-in girlfriend. A conviction for this type of offense would have ruined his career, as he had an outstanding job offer to be a university professor at an out-of-state university. We immediately contacted our client’s girlfriend and spoke with her at length. She did not want the case prosecuted but thought that our client needed some anger management and alcohol classes. We also got character letters from our client’s PhD professors and had our client submit his resume. We then approached the prosecutor with the statement from our client’s girlfriend, as well as the letters from his PhD professors and his resume. We also brought proof that our client had been attending AA and had already begun addressing his drinking problem. Initially, the prosecutor offered to put him on probation for 1 year. However, we explained to the prosecutor that this would ruin his career and jeopardize his university job. Ultimately, we were able to convince the prosecutor to dismiss the case with the condition that our client do anger management and alcohol classes.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed; continued on probation

Possession of Marijuana; Motion to Revoke Felony Probation

Client was a young man with only one prior criminal arrest: a felony possession of a controlled substance charge in another county. We were not his lawyer for that charge, and he was already on probation when he became our client. While on felony probation, he was arrested for possession of marijuana in Travis County. Before seeking our representation, the client had spent five (5) months in jail waiting for the Caldwell County court to decide whether or not to revoke his probation due to the offense in Travis County. Upon their decision, he was shipped from the Caldwell Jail to the Travis County Jail to take care of the possession of marijuana charge. After meeting with the client and reviewing the police report, we were fortunate to find a prosecutor that was sympathetic to his plight. The search of our client was incredibly suspect; as he was leaving his car and heading back to his girlfriend’s apartment, the police officer stopped him, claiming “this was a high crime area” and he wanted to investigate whether or not our client was burglarizing his own car. The police officer then looked inside the car, said that he saw a marijuana cigar in plain view, and arrested our client for possession of marijuana. The problem with his search was twofold: first, it would be impossible to determine whether a cigar contained marijuana by sight alone. Second, considering that our client had car keys, no shoes, no burglary tools, wasn’t running or hiding from the police, and was outside an apartment complex, there was no reasonable suspicion to believe that he was engaged in criminal activity. We were able to contact the client’s probation officer to confirm that he was scheduled to attend drug treatment in the coming weeks. When we put the probation officer on the phone with the prosecutor, who confirmed his treatment, the case was dismissed.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; misdemeanor reduced to a ticket and $200 fine

Felony Possession of Controlled Substance; Misdemeanor possession of controlled substance

Client was a college-aged Mexican American charged with a felony and misdemeanor possession of cocaine and possession of controlled substance. After reviewing all police reports, extensive meetings with the client and viewing the scene, we successfully argued that the police had no probable cause to detain the client. (Police said that he looked suspicious because he went into an apartment with an empty backpack and left the apartment minutes later with something in the bag. Police believed this was probable cause for burglary. We immediately contested this case and argued that it was completely unconstitutional to search someone who had done nothing wrong. Every single activity that our Client had done was consistent with someone who lived in an apartment complex. There was no indication that he was burglarizing, no burglary tools were found, and no evidence was ever found suggesting that he was doing anything other than getting stuff from his apartment. Thankfully, the District Attorney agreed this was an illegal detention and agreed to dismiss the felony charge before a pretrial hearing.

Read More

Result:

All felonies DISMISSED and client pleaded to two counts Possession of Marijuana and received time served.

Client charged with five felonies – three for Possession of a Controlled Substance – Cocaine and Methamphetamines and two for Delivery of a Controlled Substance (contested litigation) (jail release) (codefendants)

Client was charged with 5 felonies – 3 for possessions and 2 for delivery of cocaine and methamphetamines. After a meeting with her and with our social worker, she asserted her innocence. Although a tremendous amount of drugs were found in her house with a search warrant, she claimed that she had nothing to do with it. Her relatives were actively involved in the presence of the drugs, but not her. Considering the large amount of drugs present, it was a challenge proving that she was not connected with them. Client was being detained on close to $100,000.00 for a bond, meaning she had no chance for a PR Bond. Within the first month, the DA had made offers to all the people who were arrested under terrible terms – 10 years in prison with 10 years Probation and Community Service fines. We had recommended against this because our Client claimed she was totally innocent and that it wasn’t hers. We had to work quite hard to convince the Client not to take the deal because she was eager to get out of jail. After we started investigating the case, we were able to prove more and more that she was telling the truth. With the information we were uncovering, we had some pre-trial hearings to suppress the evidence. Through our research and investigation, we also found out that although the police had a search warrant, they executed it incorrectly. Instead of announcing their presence by knocking, they failed to do this as required in the warrant and there are no legal or factual exceptions regarding circumstances that would justify their immediate intrusion into her home. Armed with this information and the case law, we proceeded to a pre-trial hearing and suffice it to say, our arguments were persuasive enough during the hearing that when the Judge recessed the hearing, we approached the bench about letting our Client out on a PR bond with an electronic monitor. The Judge agreed and put her on house arrest. Upon release, our Client was doing well – she had a regular job, no criminal record, etc. She was elated at the possibility of getting all of these charges dismissed. Unfortunately, about a month later the police got another search warrant for her home, kicked down the door again, and sure enough, found more drugs. This jeopardized all of our work to this point and seriously threw her innocence into doubt. Once the DA found out, he was livid and said that our Client was clearly involved in the drug ring. After a very lengthy conversation with her in jail, we continued to stand by her version of the events. Within 12 hours we were able to speak to witnesses to find out what happened during the second arrest. We were able to provide enough convincing evidence to show that she was not a part of any dealing, selling, or using of drugs. Despite facing five felony charges, the case was resolved with all charges dismissed and her pleading guilty to 2 possessions of marijuana counts and getting a sentence of 2 days in jail and 30 days in jail (which she had already served in the early stages of the case). The Client was incredibly appreciative that we stuck with her when nobody else believed in her innocence. We were able to get an outstanding outcome.

Read More

Result:

Not Guilty

Assault (trial)

Client was a charged with striking the school principal as she was attempting to break up a fight. Through cross-examination we were able to show her bias towards our client and confirm that her back was turned when she was hit. Furthermore, we found another witness that confirmed client’s story that the contact with the principal was incidental as client admitted to touching the principal, but only because he was pushed by another student. Client was found Not Guilty at trial.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Assault Family Violence

Client was charged with grabbing his estranged wife about the head and neck as they argued one evening. A key witness disagreed with facts in the offense report and gave an alternative explanation for the altercation which was grossly different. The police believed the complainant over the witness. We set the case for a jury trial after the prosecution refused to dismiss based upon the discrepancy of the statements. On the day of trial the charge was dismissed after further exculpatory evidence corroborated that the complainant was exaggerating.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed after successful completion of deferred prosecution

Assault on a Peace Officer

Client and three of his friends were coming from a bar on 6th St. and ended up getting involved in a rather large scuffle with two undercover police officers. The two central issues were: who started the fight, and whether or not one of the police officers really shouted “POLICE!” and showed his badge as was disputed by witness statements. A tremendous amount of investigation went into this case, including subpoenaing all of the police records, witnesses, officers, personnel files, etc. The City Attorney had tried to quash our subpoenas and the Attorney General had not initially allowed for the release of a lot of information. However, we were successful in getting all of the records released and found that the officer involved had a history of excessive force. In addition, there were hospital records that showed that some of the injuries the police officer claimed to have sustained were not true, as well as being able to find the other witnesses and bringing to light conflicting stories. The hardest issue was disproving numerous witnesses who said that our client threw the first punch. It took a large amount of time re-enactment the fight with witnesses to show that it would have been impossible for the fight to have happened in the way that these witnesses said. Thankfully, we were blessed with a very patient prosecutor who allowed us to explain our case in depth (with charts and diagrams) before trial commenced. On the morning of trial, the case was resolved.

Read More

Result:

Won the parole revocation hearing

Parole Revocation Hearing

As client was accused of a violent felony, our client was also facing a revocation of parole. Even though the felony was dismissed the client’s parole officer still sought his revocation. We prevailed at the hearing and client retained his freedom.

Read More

Result:

Jury Trial – Not Guilty

Indecent Exposure

While client was at the drive through lane at a local bank, two tellers thought they saw him expose his genitals. They were absolutely mistaken, but this presented a classic case as to why we have jury trials. Through co-counsel’s dogged investigation (measuring the angles and tint from the teller window), we argued and the jury believed that they could not have been able to see his genitals as he was seated in the car. Client was acquitted (in Williamson County, of all places) and the arrest was permanently removed from his record.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Minor in Possession

Our client was an Honors UT student and was at a party. The police were called and they arrested everybody that was underage without doing a thorough investigation. Our client, who was under 21, had never been a drinker, nor was she drinking that night. Even though the prosecutor was offering a deferred disposition, our client did not want to plead guilty to something she was not guilty of. The case was dismissed before trial.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed

Places Weapons Prohibited – 3rd Degree Felony

A knife was found in client’s bag as he boarded a plane for a business trip. Client had no idea the 5 ¼” hunting knife was there. In order to convince the prosecutor of this we obtained written statements from the client and his wife regarding circumstances surrounding how the knife was placed into his bag during a recent move into a new home. This information was submitted to the prosecutor along with a packet of documents supporting facts within their statements. Based on this information and several face-to-face meetings, charges were reduced to a Class C misdemeanor that would be erased from client’s record.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed

Unlawful possession of firearm on licensed premises

Our client was accused of pulling out a gun from his boot at a gas station. A woman who supposedly saw this happen in front of her called the cops and provided a clothing description and location of our client. Within minutes, several cops arrived on scene and drew their guns and ordered our client to the ground. They searched him and found a gun in his boot and charged him with unlawful possession of a firearm on a licensed premises. The first offer in court was 7 years TDC which we rejected. The prosecutor then came down and offered 2 years probation; however, our client faced immigration consequences with a conviction of this type of crime. We did extensive legal research and discovered several cases that were on point that stated that the cops cannot execute a full-on arrest based on an anonymous tip, such as the one in our case. The law supported our possession that our client was arrested illegally and thus, any evidence discovered as a result of that illegal arrest must be suppressed. We then set the case for trial and provided the prosecutor with our caselaw. Ultimately, the prosecutor agreed with our position and dismissed all charges against our client.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed

Unauthorized Use of a Motor Vehicle

Our client was a passenger in a truck that had been pulled over for a traffic violation. As the cops were questioning the driver of the truck, they noticed that the steering column had been broken so they decided to call in to see if it had been reported stolen. Dispatch came back with the information that the truck had in fact been stolen so the cops decided to arrest the driver and our client, the passenger. The original offer by the DA was 5 years probation on this felony offense. However, our client was a young man with a clean criminal record and we felt that it would be detrimental for him to have a felony on his record so we advised him not to accept the offer. In the meantime, we found supporting case that stated that it is not proper to charge a passenger with that statute because he was not the one actually “using” the motor vehicle. We approached the prosecutor with this case and he agreed to dismiss all the charges.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; deferred adjudication on misdemeanor

Stalking

Stemming from an intimate relationship with another University of Texas student, client was accused of stalking him, because of correspondence, voicemail messages and behavior at the complainant’s dorm. We subpoenaed all records from the school, as well as client’s health records. Through investigation it was discovered that, while some of the client’s behavior might be considered annoying to complainant, there was nothing to show that client’s behavior was in any way threatening of bodily injury or harm to the complainant, a necessary element of a felony stalking charge. It also became clear that police may have attempted to influence the complainant to prosecute when he had previously not wanted criminal consequences for our client. After almost a year, the State agreed to reduce the case to a Class B misdemeanor and deferred adjudication probation for nine months, allowing client’s case to be dismissed when she completes probation successfully.

Read More

Result:

Reversed & Judgment of Acquittal rendered

Appeal

Client was found guilty after a jury trial for criminal mischief for smashing out windows of a car in a foolish display of anger. Client was very concerned about having a criminal conviction on her record because she was applying for a job with the IRS. After drafting and submitting the an appellate brief on her behalf, the State, in its reply brief, conceded error and asked the Third Court of Appeals to reverse her conviction and render a judgment of acquittal, which it did. (Note: this rarely happens)

Read More

Result:

Client successfully discharged from probation

Motion to Revoke Probation

Client was on probation for DWI. Client was charged with failing to adhere to conditions of probation, specifically, failing to complete community service, failing to pay monthly fees, and failing to report to his probation officer. We obtained proof of client’s fee payments and provided documentation of client’s hospital stay for in-patient treatment for bi-polar disorder and drug abuse which prevented him from meeting with his probation officer. Client was successfully discharged from community supervision.

Read More

Result:

Client successfully continued on probation with no arrest and no jail time for the violation.

Motion to Revoke Felony Probation

Client was on 10 years felony probation for a drug offense. While he had been doing well on probation, after going through serious marital problems, he ended up using drugs one evening. On his next visit to his probation officer, he tested positive for drugs and his probation officer told him they would be issuing a motion to revoke his probation. The client came to our office in a panic because subsequent to his positive drug test, things had actually been going a lot better for him. He had a great and stable job and he was in the middle of resolving issues and reconciling with his wife; going to prison would destroy everything. Once he retained us, we immediately coordinated with a private drug rehabilitation program and helped to get him in enrolled. Simultaneously, we went to the court and met with the Judge and convinced him not to sign the warrant to have our client arrested but rather, to let him appear in court on his own so we could explain everything to the judge without having our client be in jail (even though this was the second time the State was trying to revoke his probation). At the next court setting, we provided the judge all of the confirmation of our client’s rehabilitation program. The judge reset the case to see if our client could successfully complete his program and when we next appeared in court and showed proof of successful completion, the judge continued our client on probation.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed through pretrial diversion

Theft

Client was accused of shoplifting. Client had financial resources and there was no reason why he would be caught shoplifting, but two witnesses were adamant about him taking a bag of clothes from a store without paying. Client was undergoing a very nasty divorce at the time and was on medication to help him get through this. Because of these circumstances, the client left the store without paying unintentionally or that he believed he had already paid. Ultimately, was accepted into pretrial diversion which he successfully completed.

Read More

Result:

Not Guilty at trial

Theft

Client’s twin had shoplifted items, yet he was charged. The prosecutor refused to believe this and thought there was some trick. The State refused to dismiss charges until the day of trial. Both brothers provided statements which corroborated our explanation from the beginning and client (the innocent twin) was exonerated.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; misdemeanor probation

Aggravated Assault with a Deadly Weapon

Client was arrested for a fight in which the complaining witness suffered deep cuts to her calf muscle with a razor blade. The police did not believe client’s claim of self-defense, and multiple witnesses gave conflicting accounts about the events leading up to the fight. Through thorough investigation, we began to build a solid foundation outlining client’s case of self-defense. Felony charges were reduced to misdemeanor assault.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed

Aggravated Robbery

While awaiting trial on another charge, client was arrested for allegedly participating in a robbery of a disabled person. Through surveillance and numerous witness interviews, we were able to prove that the complaining witness in this case was attempting to blackmail our client. Ultimately, the case was dismissed. The District Attorney was originally seeking to send client to prison.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Assault Family Violence

Our client was accused of assaulting his wife. Upon interviewing his wife, however, it turned out that she was actually the aggressor and had a history of assaulting our client. She did not want the case prosecuted, but she didn’t want to get in trouble, either. We presented this information to the prosecutor; however, she still did not want to drop the case because our client had been arrested in the past for the same offense. We set the case for trial and then on the day of trial, the prosecutor ultimately decided to dismiss the case after meeting with our witnesses.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed and refiled as a misdemeanor which was dismissed pursuant to deferred prosecution

Retaliation (3rd Degree Felony)

The client was arrested for public intoxication and during his ride back to the station, began threatening the police officer which led to the Retaliation charges. We immediately realized that the client’s behavior was due to his intoxication and that he possibly had a substance abuse problem. We immediately enrolled our client into treatment and met with the prosecutor early on about not indicting the case. After several additional meetings, the prosecutor agreed to refile the case as a misdemeanor and we then were able to convince the prosecutor to allow our client to enter into deferred prosecution whereby our client agreed to continue treatment and do community service.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed and refiled as a misdemeanor which was dismissed pursuant to pretrial diversion.

Assault on a Public Servant (3rd Degree Felony)

This case occurred during the Barack Obama rally in downtown Austin. There were barricades that had been erected around the Capitol and the client was attempting to get back to work when she was confronted by a man in a gray suit who indicated that she was not authorized to go back to work. At one point, the client, not knowing who the man was, attempted to step across the barrier and was tackled by the man, who happened to be a Secret Service Agent. During the struggle, the client was accused of hitting the agent and she was charged with Assault on a Public Servant. Because the agent was in plain clothes, there was a dispute as to whether our client knew he was an agent. If we could show that she did not know he was an agent, she would have been authorized under the self-defense statute to protect herself. Luckily, the incident was captured on television and we were able to obtain that and prove that there was no visible badge and that it would have been very unlikely to assume the agent was a public servant. In addition, the client, who had never been in trouble before, had amazing character letters that poured in from all over. In addition, during our investigation, we learned that the agent was upset because his suit had been ruined in the scuffle. Therefore, we made an offer to pay for a replacement suit and to have our client do community services in lieu of dismissing the case.

Read More

Result:

Sexual Assault no-billed by the Grand Jury.

Sexual Assault

While Client was in the middle of a bad custody dispute with his ex-wife, she made a false report to the police that he had raped her. She also made accusations that our client had been physically and emotionally abused her throughout their marriage. She was able to convince the police department to file sexual assault charges against Client. As soon as the warrant came out, we assisted Client in doing a walk-through and then vigorously began our defense. Our strategy was to do everything possible to avoid an indictment so we began to prepare our defense to present to the grand jury to prevent an indictment which we were ultimately able to do.

Read More

Result:

Deadly Conduct dismissed

Deadly Conduct

Our client was accused of shooting off a gun in a neighborhood on New Year's Eve. We put together a mitigation package and met with the prosecutor and proposed an alternative to prosecution which included mandating our client attend a gun safety course and do community service. The prosecutor agreed and allowed our client to adhere to our proposal in exchange for dismissing the charges.

Read More

Result:

DWI charges not filed, case dismissed

Driving While Intoxicated

Our client was pulled over for speeding and was asked to submit to the Field Sobriety Tests and the Breath Test after the officer suspected he was intoxicated. Our client, who was not intoxicated, knew that he had a fifth amendment right to not incriminate himself and he immediately invoked his right to a lawyer and refused all tests. Frustrated that our client refused the tests, the officer arrested our client for DWI. We helped our client get out of jail and we immediately had our client take a private blood test proving he had no alcohol or drugs in his system. We then made an immediate appointment with the prosecutor and were able to convince him to not file the charges.

Read More

Result:

2 years federal probation

Conspiracy to Manufacture Marijuana

Our client was charged with helping to set up multiple marijuana grow operations in Austin. We were able to provide mitigating evidence and show that our client was a very minor participant in the conspiracy. Ultimately, the prosecutor agreed to let our client plead guilty to a reduced charge and dismissed the conspiracy charge. Result: Felony Conspiracy dismissed, client convicted on a lesser charge and received two years probation.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Felony Graffiti

Client was charged with felony graffiti for spray painting the walls of a local high school. The client’s family hired us immediately, before charges were formally filed. Before the charges were filed, we immediately contacted the prosecutor and offered to pay the restitution – the amount spent having to remove the graffiti and repaint - to avoid the filing of the case. The prosecutor agreed but by a clerical oversight, the case was filed. We were able to convince the prosecutor to stand by her word and she dismissed the case outright.

Read More

Result:

Grand jury no-billed case

Aggravated Assault

Our client was accused of stabbing a man outside of a gas station. This was a very serious case because our client was on parole and had a civil case pending against TDC. If he was convicted of this new offense, he would have been sent back to TDC where he feared he would be retaliated against because of his civil lawsuit. Our client had indicated that this was a self-defense case and that the other man was extremely intoxicated and had jumped on top of him and began to assault him which is why he had defended himself. We immediately went to the gas station to interview employees there who told us that they remembered the incident and knew both of the people involved. They told us that the alleged victim was extremely intoxicated and had been harassing and yelling at customers. The employees then told us that while they did not see the actual fight (which happened behind the gas station), that our client had come in running and was acting very scared and would not go outside. We were able to confirm through other witnesses that the alleged victim had done some very bizarre things that day that did not make sense. Ultimately, we were able to get the charges dismissed. We then helped to represent our client at the parole revocation hearing and we prevailed in that case as well.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed, warrant fees waived.

Old traffic tickets and over $800 warrant fees

Based on the fact that client had served time in jail on a different case and had mental health concerns, the Mitigation Judge at Municipal Court agreed to dismiss client’s tickets and waive over $800 in warrant fees.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed outright

Criminal Trespass

Young homeless woman was arrested for being in backyard of an abandoned building. Case was set for “jail call;” I argued that the backyard of a non-fenced yard of an abandoned building should not be considered a criminal offense and that this was more a result of her trying to stay warm. Also raised fact that client had no criminal history. State agreed to dismiss.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed

Assault with Bodily Injury/Family Violence

Client’s abusive ex-boyfriend broke into her house and assaulted her and her children when they tried to protect her. Our client caused some pretty extensive injuries, but I was able to prove they were self-defense. I also obtained a statement from the CW proving that he lied to the officers; this was also provided to client’s CPS attorney to use in her CPS case. Case dismissed with proof of April’s attending SafePlace. April reports that SafePlace has been invaluable to her and she is still attending groups. I feel that this experience has been truly life-changing for her.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed outright

Possession of Drug Paraphernalia

Client charged with having a jar that was suspected to have held marijuana. Argued that this was nothing but officer’s suspicion and therefore no probable cause.

Read More

Result:

Felony credit card abuse charge dismissed; reduced to Class C disorderly conduct

Credit Card Abuse

Soldier on leave from Killeen was arrested, along with two other soldiers, for using credit cards they found in a purse in a parking lot. Investigated case, talked to witnesses, and State agreed to dismiss case and refile as a Class C Disorderly Conduct charge upon payment of restitution.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed

Minor in Possession

Hockey player was at park with high school friends who had a backpack with alcohol inside. Prosecutor agreed to dismiss case upon my presenting him with a negative drug/alcohol screen and proof that client took an alcohol class.

Read More

Result:

Pretrial Diversion - Dismissed

Burglary of a Building

Client in Rio Grande Valley charged with burglarizing his former place of employment. Due to mitigation evidence and argument of counsel, prosecutor agreed to pretrial diversion program for client.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed outright

Driving While License Invalid with Three Previous Convictions

Client stopped for parking wrong way while dropping his children off at school. State agreed to dismiss after he obtained car insurance.

Read More

Result:

Both felonies dismissed

State Jail Felony (two counts) (juvenile)

Client was riding the bus on his way home from school. At the bus stop he saw a large group of kids at a middle school and client went to see what was going on. Several kids were spray painting a school building and soon the police arrived. Client was identified by another student and by police as being one who had participated in the spray painting. Client maintained his innocence all along. When the prosecutor refused to dismiss the charge (an offer of 3 months probation was made) we set the case for trial. Just prior to trial the state agreed that there may have been a mistake made concerning the identification of client as one who participated in the painting, and the case was dismissed.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed after successful completion of deferred prosecution

Burglary of a Habitation (juvenile) (co-defendants) (litigation)

Client was charged with BOH and it was alleged that he had entered an apartment through a window and opened the front door for three other boys. Client was very young and this was his first contact with the system. He was in the fourth grade and he had repeated third grade because of academic problems. He was going to school and doing the best he could, but he was caught pretty much red-handed.

Read More

Result:

Client no longer required to register

Sex Offender Registration (juvenile) (contested litigation)

Client was required to register as a sex offender after having been adjudicated as a juvenile. Client hired us to get his registration excused prior to the expiration of the 10 years he was required to register. At the time he hired us, client was 21 years old and was about to graduate from the University of Texas. He was married with a baby girl and had a promising future ahead of him in the field of engineering. He had never again been in trouble with the law. However, throughout his high school and college experience, he had difficulty obtaining jobs-even hourly, minimum wage jobs, because of background checks that showed him to be a registered sex offender. Given his field of engineering, many if not all career positions-especially government positions would be closed to him because of this status.

After a hearing before the District judge, we won the motion and client was excused from further registration as a sex offender, and his juvenile record was sealed.

Read More

Result:

Opposing counsel conceded

Civil suit – motion to designate a responsible third party (written pleadings)

Defendant attempts to drag our corporate client into a multimillion dollar wrongful death suit. After filing a designation to declare our client a responsible third party, we draft a lengthy objection and serve on all parties. Two weeks before the hearing, the opposing counsel conceded that our client was not involved and removed the company from the lawsuit.

Read More

Result:

Felony and all charges dismissed

Felony Assault on Peace Officer; Criminal Trespass (mental health)

Client was a man who suffered from severe brain damage and epileptic seizures and who had previously been found to be legally incompetent by a civil court and had an appointed guardian. Our client had just had a seizure in his front yard and had accidentally walked into the house of his neighbor, a 70-year old woman. Once inside her house, our client had gone into a post-catatonic state on her couch and would not leave when asked. Because the neighbor was scared, she called the cops hoping they could come and help our client to his house. Once the cops arrived, they started yelling orders at our client to leave and because of his post-catatonic state, he was unable to hear and thus, could not comply. Instead of helping our client in his post-catatonic state, the cops began to try to physically remove our client from the couch. In doing so, our client began to flail his arms and legs which caused contact with the cops. The cops then began to use their tazers on our client which only exacerbated the situation. When we got the case, we immediately contacted our client’s legal guardian and began to get information on his medical records and medical conditions. We set up an appointment with the prosecutors office and appeared at this meeting with our client’s legal guardian. While there, we explained the situation and presented evidence of our client’s mental illness. Ultimately, we were able to convince the prosecutors to dismiss all charges.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Possession of Marijuana

Client was accused of possession of marijuana, and failed to appear in court. He was classified as a fugitive for about a year, was arrested on the warrant, and we were appointed to represent him. When we met with the prosecution, we reviewed the police report and were able to show a number of defects which made the search and arrest of our client illegal. Although the County Attorney was upset that the client had absconded for that length of time, she agreed with the fundamental flaws of the search after reviewing the caselaw we provided. The case was dismissed, and client was released from jail.

Read More

Result:

Felony and all cases dismissed

Two Felony and two Misdemeanor Possession charges

Client was accused of 2 felonies and 2 misdemeanors and a search warrant drug raid in his home. Client was charged with possession of a number of drugs. We were able to show how the client was not involved in any of the drug dealing or drug possession whatsoever based on the schematics of the apartment and photographs of where he was, where the trash can was, and where the drug residue was found. It was a trash can that he did not have access to. All cases were dismissed.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Robbery (juvenile) (co-defendants)

Juvenile client was charged with robbery for supposedly placing an ice-cream vendor in fear for his life and robbing him. Investigation by defense discovered that the ice-cream vendor was not in fear but was just mad and upset that one of the boys did not pay for an ice cream. Ice cream man acknowledged that he exaggerated when confronted with additional facts, and State dismissed the case.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed through drug court diversion

Possession of a Controlled Substance, Felony – Enhanced (25 years to life)

Our client was charged with possession of cocaine. Although this would normally be a state jail felony, because our client had two prior felony convictions, he was “habitualized” and was facing 25-life if he was convicted. Because our client had a substance abuse problem, we immediately tried to get him into the SHORT program, which is a drug diversion program in Travis County. The SHORT program initially denied him based on some mental health issues, as well as the fact that our client was homeless. In order to address those issues, we had our client evaluated by a MHMR liaison to see if he needed any medication to stabilize him. We also coordinated with a half-way house and were able to find him placement there. With that information, we then re-approached the SHORT program and wrote a letter on his behalf to re-consider him. The SHORT program did decide to reconsider him and ultimately accepted him into the program.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; sex offender registration avoided

Attempted Sexual Assault (Felony); Assault Family Violence (Misdemeanor)

This was a difficult case with a difficult client. This case was especially taxing because the complainant was so reasonable and our client was so obnoxious. (These are things that defense lawyers aren’t probably supposed to say, but it’s the truth. Although 99% of our clients are wonderful people, sometimes you represent an absolute…knucklehead.)
Our client was accused of getting into a physical altercation with his wife over a dispute about family finances. The assault was bad, the photos of the injuries were worse, but the allegation of sexual assault that allegedly occurred in the midst of the fight were completely out of left field. While there was little factual dispute about the assault, the central issue was whether or our client attempted to sexually assault his wife during a fight.
We spent a number of hours in meetings with the complainant—who was an incredibly nice woman that had clearly been in an abusive relationship. Through the use of Defense Initiated Victim Outreach we were able to work through many of the communication problems and issues within the relationship for her perspective. Much of our work was with our client who initially refused to see his actions as anything other than appropriately justified. Stubbornly, he chose to spend many weeks in jail rather than deal with the underlying problems. By the third month in jail, he became more receptive, in large part because his wife ignored his pathetic attempts to paint himself as the victim.
While I wish I could say that somehow the client magically turned around his perspective, he didn’t. He acknowledged that he has a tremendous anger management problem, and he may have realized that he inherited his contempt for women because of the way he witnesses his father treat his mother. There were moments of clarity and genuine remorse. There was a lot more that needed to be done than we achieved.
Ultimately, our client came to the conclusion that the right thing to do was to take responsibility for the physical assault, he was found guilty and he served a jail sentence. The State wanted to have him register as a sex-offender and put on a lengthy felony probation term because they didn’t like what he did, but it became clear to all parties that the fight was not sexual in nature.
This case was an interesting success story for third reasons. First, it presents the issue of zealous advocacy for an unlikeable client. Even though the client did something wrong, he shouldn’t have to register as a sex offender if that wasn’t the underlying issue. Second, it reaffirmed our duty of loyalty when we personally felt that the opposing party was more likeable. Third, it reminded us that in the real world, you can’t change everybody and magically solve everybody’s problems. We tried to help, we failed, and sometimes success is knowing that you did the best that you could do.

Read More

Result:

Not Guilty

Assault – Family Violence

Client was charged with assaulting an ex-girlfriend by beating her with a cane and strangling her. Client vehemently denied the charges and asserted that his ex-girlfriend was simply angry at him for having a new girlfriend. Client was on parole for murder and faced life in prison if convicted on a new assault case. The case proceeded to a jury trial and client was found not guilty by the jury after 15 minutes of deliberations.

Read More

Result:

Felony dismissed; mental health probation

Aggravated Assault on Peace Officer; Unlawful Carrying Weapon

Client had a history of severe mental health problems. While in prison, he had been violently raped and brutalized so badly that he contracted numerous diseases and began a pattern of antagonizing prison guards solely to be placed in protective custody. In battling the pain of untreated mental health issues, client attempted to commit suicide by threatening a police officer in hopes of being shot. The officer who responded was nothing short of outstanding; he knew our client from the neighborhood and did an excellent job of calming him down. He assured the family that he would try to get the client help, and that he wasn’t going to charge him with anything more than a misdemeanor. The police Sergeant disagreed and pushed for our client to be indicted on the felony. Ultimately, we got in touch with the officer and coordinating a conference call with the DA. The felony was dismissed and our client was placed on a mental health caseload and received excellent care.

Read More

Result:

Client successfully continued on probation with no arrest and no jail time for the violation

Motion to Revoke Felony Probation

Client was on 10 years felony probation for a drug offense. While he had been doing well on probation, after going through serious marital problems, he ended up using drugs one evening. On his next visit to his probation officer, he tested positive for drugs and his probation officer told him they would be issuing a motion to revoke his probation. The client came to our office in a panic because subsequent to his positive drug test, things had actually been going a lot better for him. He had a great and stable job and he was in the middle of resolving issues and reconciling with his wife; going to prison would destroy everything. Once he retained us, we immediately coordinated with a private drug rehabilitation program and helped to get him in enrolled. Simultaneously, we went to the court and met with the Judge and convinced him not to sign the warrant to have our client arrested but rather, to let him appear in court on his own so we could explain everything to the judge without having our client be in jail (even though this was the second time the State was trying to revoke his probation). At the next court setting, we provided the judge all of the confirmation of our client’s rehabilitation program. The judge reset the case to see if our client could successfully complete his program and when we next appeared in court and showed proof of successful completion, the judge continued our client on probation.

Read More

Result:

DWI dismissed; deferred prosecution.

Possession of a Controlled Substance (State Jail Felony)

Client was in a car accident and when police arrived on scene, they searched Client and discovered cocaine. Early on in our representation, we suspected that our client had a substance abuse issue so we had our social worker conduct a full assessment and put together a treatment plan. We then presented our findings and our plan to the prosecutor and she agreed to dismiss the charges as long as our client adhered to our recommended plan.

Read More

Result:

Case dismissed

Burglary of Habitation

Our client was accused of breaking into a outdoor area of a restaurant and stealing merchandise. After doing legal research on what constituted a “building” we were able to find caselaw that supported our position that the area our client was accused of going on to was not considered a building under the statute. The DA agreed and dismissed all the charges.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed outright

Possession of Prohibited Weapon

Katrina evacuee was charged with possessing brass knuckles after he called police to his house after his vehicle was burglarized. Based on argument of counsel, State dismissed case at first setting.

Read More

Result:

Dismissed

Assault with Bodily Injury/Family Violence

Client’s abusive boyfriend called cops on her after she defended herself against him. Case dismissed after client attended SafePlace Intake and got help for her abusive living situation.

Read More

Result:

Not revoked. Probation extended.

MTR/Criminal Trespass

Pro bono from Lifeworks. Lifeworks called us about this client. The client was on the “jail chain” and had a court-appointed lawyer who, apparently, was going to plea her to at least one of her two new cases in order to keep her on probation—and within the Court’s jurisdiction—longer. We agreed to take the client pro bono and substituted in as counsel. We got the client out of jail on a PR bond with the assurance that we would make sure she got to her ANEW appointment so her mental health issues could be evaluated. While she was out on bond waiting to see a Dr. at ANEW, our client picked up two new charges. We got her out on personal bond again. She now had five pending cases—her Motion To Revoke Probation and four new cases. We talked to various people in the county attorney’s office to explain the client’s mental health issues and, most important, our social worker worked hard to get her evaluated at ANEW, after which she was placed on meds, and to help her with job and housing applications. After we were able to demonstrate that the client had made significant strides, we were able to negotiate an extension on the client’s probation and a dismissal of all four of her new cases.

Read More

Result:

The police officer argued that he had followed the defendant for a mile and a half to two miles before client was pulled over; going through lights, on a highway, and exits, etc. He says that the client must either have been too intoxicated or evading his arrest and trying to ignore him. Aside from that, there were two separate occasions where the client was given field sobriety tests and the police officer said he failed them both: one on scene, and second in the police holding room. We disagreed. Client clearly had some problems with the one-leg stand, but our argument in the case was that the client was not intoxicated and we had two witnesses to testify himself as to his very minor level of impairment. The case was resolved after we were able to show some parts of that video as well as showing some inconsistencies with the Officer’s testimony and how it was likely to change again, for a fourth time, at trial.

Driving While Intoxicated

DWI dismissed; deferred adjudication on obstruction of a public passageway

Read More

Result:

Client was pulled over and admitted to drinking five (5) alcoholic beverages that evening. In the midst of the field sobriety tests, another car on the highway crashes into the backup patrol car. Police officer throws client on the median and the prosecutor argues to the jury that the police officer is a hero and client was intoxicated because he didn’t react in time. Defense theory concedes that police officer did the right thing by pulling him out of harm’s way, but it was incredibly unfair and unreliable to continue field sobriety tests after such a traumatic event. Jury hangs 3-3 and State offers a non-DWI offense before retrying the case for a second time.

Driving While Intoxicated

DWI dismissed after hung jury; deferred adjudication on obstruction of a public passageway

Read More

Result:

The client was stopped on I-35 with beer bottles in his car and the State believed he was drinking and driving. The officer’s report conclusively stated that the client failed every field sobriety test, but through argument and interpretation of video, the State was convinced that the police officer was incorrect in their interpretation of the client’s performance.

Driving While Intoxicated (open container)

DWI dismissed; deferred prosecution.

Read More

Result:

DWI dismissed

Driving While Intoxicated (refusal)

While client was on deferred prosecution awaiting dismissal, police officer pulls client over asking to perform field sobriety tests on basis of one drink 5 hours ago and faint odor of alcohol. Client refuses citing advice from counsel. Police arrest in spite of the fact that client articulately explains what he is doing and has full control of physical faculties.

Read More

Result:

DUI dismissed

Driving Under the Influence (collision)

College student client and her friends were having a gathering in a hotel and the police knock on the door, determine that everyone was underage using, confiscate alcohol, and issue Minors in Possession of Alcohol. Later in the evening, client was rear-ended by a truck at a high rate of speed. That woman did not have insurance and decided to flee the scene. The passenger in client’s car ran her down on foot and stopped her vehicle. As all this unfolds, the same police officer from earlier arrives and arrests her for driving under the influence. Case was resolved with a dismissal after relaying the facts and circumstances of the situation to the prosecutor, the fact that she was hit, showing the accident reports and driving records, producing records of client’s attendance at college out of state, and showing all of the things that she has done and has never been in trouble before.

Read More

Result:

DWI dismissed

Driving While Intoxicated

When the police pulled our client over, client was extremely upset because she had just been in a huge fight with her daughter. Unfortunately, she was somewhat belligerent with the cop because she had serious concerns about the stated reason he pulled her over. After reviewing the video, we agreed that she had reason to be upset: there was absolutely no basis for the patrol stop. We set the case for a motion to suppress because we felt the cop had pulled her over illegally. On the day of the pretrial hearing on the motion to suppress, the prosecutor agreed that it was an illegal detention and dismissed the case.

Read More

Questions?
 

Contact our office to discuss your case. We're here to help.

Sumpter, Gonzalez, & Carroll, LLP. All Rights Reserved. Principal Office: Austin, Texas. David M. Gonzalez is Board Certified in Criminal Law. 

bottom of page